Thursday, December 1, 2011

Video Game Movies

As Hollywood continues to pass over daring and original stories in favor of proven brand name properties, video games have rapidly become a regular source of popcorn fodder.  Unlike the comic book superhero trend, which continues to chug along with no signs of stopping (and, in my opinion, continues to provide some pretty solid entertainment as well), video game movies are rarely successful enough to blossom into the franchises that studios hope they become, and are openly reviled by gamers and non-gamers alike.  Sure, there are exceptions, but they are very few and far between.

The reasons should be fairly obvious to anyone who isn't a Hollywood yes man.  A movie means removing the interactivity of a game, which instantly shuts off a huge part of what makes games work in the first place.  Audiences have no control over what happens on the screen, and no control means less chance of any audience members bringing anything personal to the experience.  There's no chance for choices, or exploration, or just plain fun vicarious ass-kicking; the results are often very dull and flat.  Need examples?  Let's look at Doom.

From its early PC days through its evolutions on various consoles (yes, I owned Doom 64), Doom has always been about creating an atmosphere of dread closing in on a single player weaving their way through a labyrinth that is one part space station and one part Hell itself.  There's no real story, or character development, or even drama outside of the raw thrill of combat.  And there's no need for it.  The closest the games ever got to a real story was Doom 3, which fleshed out the details of the tragedy that drags a Martian colony into the very depths of Hell.


Badass!  Now, if only they could pull that off in a movie... Oh wait, they tried.  But here's the rub: take out the first person interactive experience, and what do you have?  Not much.  How do you pad out a two hour movie when the story can be summed up in a sentence?  The answer for Revolution Studios was to add more characters.  Audiences love characters, right?  Unfortunately, the last thing Doom needs is a cast.  What you get is a watered down version of Aliens with demons replacing the aliens, and haven't we seen that movie before?  There's a reason the only good part of the movie is the brief first person sequence toward the end that emulates the gameplay:


That's it - you don't need to see the rest of the movie.  That's the only good part.  Seriously.

Now, not all games are as single-minded as Doom, and yes, it's true that games are becoming more and more cinematic.  So adapting something that was originally designed to look like a movie should be a piece of cake, right?  Well, yes and no.  Resident Evil is a video game movie that should have been a no-brainer; the game has fairly simple premise, a straightforward narrative (I'm talking about the first game only - I'm well aware of how convoluted the story has become over the last several sequels), well-defined action sequences and the pacing and tension of an actual horror movie.


 Yet somehow we ended up with a movie with no brain.  Only the barest elements of the game's plot carries over into the movie.  Zombies?  Check.  Umbrella Corporation?  Check.  People trying to survive?  Check.  But where's the mansion on the outskirts of Raccoon City?  Uh, it's there, but it's just a secret entrance to a sprawling underground facility.  Where are Chris Redfield and Jill Valentine, the two main characters?  Uh, do we need them?  Where is the nefarious Albert Wesker, the villain behind this whole outbreak?  Uh, do we need him too?  How about some people running around with guns killing zombies - isn't that enough?  No?  Ok, what if there's a sexy female character thrown in?


Somehow this movie launched a franchise that has fared pretty well.  Each installment seems to try harder than the last to incorporate more of the elements that make the games so enjoyable, but there's still one major hurdle that keeps them from being good if not great: the character of Alice (Milla Jovavich).  Alice is unique to the movies, and doesn't fit in with the game mythos at all.  The harder the films try to shape the world of the games around this character, the weaker all of the material becomes, but at this point, she's married to the franchise (literally - she married Paul W. S. Anderson, director of the first and fourth films) and it's unlikely they'll ever ditch her to do things right.  It's sad that it took two films to see Raccoon City overrun while Jill Valentine tries to outrun Nemesis, three films to see a Tyrant, and four films to see Albert Wesker in action.  I'm pleased that this has become a successful franchise, but it kills me that it isn't as good as it could have been.

Yet even when video game adaptations stick pretty close to the material, they can still fail pretty miserably.  Take Prince of Persia, a film I happen to like a lot, but which failed to find the audience it deserved.  To me it had everything that makes the games fun (and keep in mind, the majority of my experience with the games has been as a spectator), and was a genuinely entertaining movie on its own.  For reasons I still don't understand it was a flop, and it's unlikely we'll see another.  And yet somehow there are no less than three Bloodrayne movies...

Which brings me to Uwe Boll.  Here is a professional hack, a genuinely awful filmmaker who has built his career on ruining one video game adaptation after another.  Anytime a major studio decides to gamble on a video game movie, I breathe a little easier once I confirm that Boll is not involved.

The other fundamental problem with video game adaptations is the casting issue.  Many classic characters are classic because of their blankness and malleability.  By attaching an actor to the character, a movie adaptation is walking a very fine line.  One the one hand, they may find an actor that resonates with audiences, becoming synonymous with that character's name forever.  On the other hand, they risk alienating the bulk of the character's fans by choosing the wrong person.  Exhibit A:


Ok, so maybe that was unfair - there's a lot more than casting that's wrong about this movie.  But casting Dennis Hopper as a giant lizard king is more than just a stretch.

Which brings me to the biggest pitfall of them all: adding, subtracting, and altering elements of the property until the film no longer resembles the property.  Super Mario Brothers is probably the all-time champion when it comes to this folly, but let's not forget Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within.  Series creator Hironobu Sakaguchi wrote, produced, and directed this lushly-animated but strangely lifeless sci-fi take on the material, stripping away the fantasy elements of mythological monsters, chocobos, and dungeons in favor of a hi-tech post-apocalyptic society at war with the ghosts of an alien culture.  This was the debut of Square's animation division, which produced this film and one of the Animatrix shorts before folding.  Everything that fans loved about Final Fantasy was thrown out the window in the hopes of reaching a wider audience with a more conventional sci-fi storyline, but by alienating the core audience, the film sealed its own fate.

Oh, and then there's the OTHER mistake - sticking with the source material to the point that you alienate any potential new audience.  The Spirits Within isn't the only CG animated film to carry the Final Fantasy name, but it is the one that reached the widest audience.  Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children is a direct sequel to the game... which is a great thing if you played the game.  If not, you're just not going to watch this movie.  The same can be said of Resident Evil: Degeneration, which is a much better RE movie than any of the Milla Jovavich films, but because it concerns characters from Resident Evil 2 and bridges the gap between RE 4 and RE 5, the chances that it will be seen by non-gamers are slim to none.

Is there a fair middle ground, a way to both placate the hardcore audience while attracting non-gamers to the multiplex?  I'd like to think there is, but as we've seen, it's tricky, and you can't just pick a game because it's popular.  Careful choices have to be made every step of the way...  Here's a list of games that I think could work as films, and what it would take to make them work:



 DEAD SPACE  Isaac Clarke's first encounter with the Marker and the necromorphs it spawns was built on the foundations of Ridley Scott's Alien; is it so hard to reverse-engineer that success?  The game has a neat, episodic narrative that can be easily streamlined into a two-hour adventure, while the game's most memorable elements - suspense, tension, atmosphere, and almost unbearable dread - are things that film excels at, and has excelled at for over a century.  That said, there have been two direct-to-DVD films (both animated) that aim to expand and deepen the game's mythos; neither is terribly good.  A cinematic approach would have to try hard not to overthink this one; the simplest tricks are often the most effective, and there's enough dramatic tension here between Isaac, his girlfriend Nicole, the other survivors of the rescue team, and the Marker itself to keep things moving.  As Isaac spends the whole game behind a mask or helmet, casting is pretty open here.

BIOSHOCK  Gore Verbinski has been campaigning for this for a while, but Universal backed out just as the project was starting to ramp up.  This is a film that needs to be made, for the very simple reason that the story is fantastic and deserves to be experienced by audiences not necessarily familiar with the game.  The introduction of an anonymous amnesiac survivor of a transatlantic plane crash to the fabulous underwater metropolis of eccentric industrialist Andrew Ryan would work just as well on film as it does in the game, if not better - audiences won't have to fiddle with selecting weapons and plasmids or hack vending machines to better their odds of survival.  This is the kind of epic sci-fi storytelling that might benefit from removing the interactivity - the world of Rapture is a truly breathtaking place, and the story of the civil war that tore it apart is so beautifully realized and cleverly scripted that it can be enjoyed with or without a controller in hand.  Verbinski apparently isn't the only party interested in making a Bioshock movie a reality; check out this recent trailer for a fan-made film:



DEVIL MAY CRY  This is rumored to be kicking around over at Screen Gems (the same guys responsible for the Resident Evil films), but I've thought for a while there could be a good movie in here.  The plots of most of the games are convoluted to the point of being incomprehensible, but this isn't the franchise for you if you're looking for plot.  Originally devised as the other side of the Resident Evil coin, this series initially used the same static camera set up and even some of the same foley effects to tell a breathless action-driven story.  It's all about flashy moves, over-the-top violence, and outrageous demon combat, and as each game in the series has become more cinematic, it's begun to look more and more likely that we'll see a movie one of these days (there's already a mediocre anime series).  A few caveats:  1) Casting is crucial here.  Whoever plays half-demon Dante has to be perfect or the whole venture will fall apart.  Names aren't as important as ability and charisma - you need a dominating screen presence who can project Dante's infamous attitude.  It may be wise to hold off until the upcoming "reboot" establishes the character's new look.  2) Keep it simple.  Dante's struggle against his evil brother Virgil is probably the best storyline as long as it's streamlined.  The fewer characters, the better - no need to bring in Nero or the women or the Jester or anything that will confuse or complicate matters.  Keep it Dante vs. Virgil, revolving around their acceptance of their demon father Sparda and their human mother.  3) Keep the marketing focused on pushing this as an action movie with horror elements, not the other way around. Oh, and if anybody wants my two cents for a choice of director, Christophe Gans (Brotherhood of the Wolf, Silent Hill) has my vote.

GEARS OF WAR  I'm just getting into this franchise, and I'm starting to understand what all the fuss is about.  It's brutal, it's challenging, and it's often laughably cliched, but man, is it fun.  With the high degree of brand recognition you can almost guarantee that a decent movie would be a hit.  The story is basically a much rougher, nastier version of Starship Troopers, a hard-as-nails war story on a distant planet where hordes of indigenous lifeforms emerge from deep underground to wipe a human colony off their planet.  It's not terribly original material, but if a movie can pull off the energy, smart design, epic scale, and tough guy banter, it could definitely work.  Check out this short teaser trailer for the second game for a hint of just how narrow the gap between hit game and hit movie could be:


GOD OF WAR  I'm dying to see a good mythological movie, especially if it's Greek mythology.  I was raised on the old Harryhausen movies and can probably recite Clash of the Titans by rote.  But just when it looked like I'd get my wish, with a remake of Clash and a Percy Jackson movie released the same year, Hollywood failed me again.  Sam Worthington just isn't a very good action hero, and The Lightning Thief just plain sucked.  My response to both films was to sulk and play some God of War.  Hey, wait a minute...  I'm not sure why some schmuck in Hollywood hasn't jumped on this one yet.  How hard could it be?  Hell, if you replaced Worthington's lame Perseus with a wrestler painted red and white, you'd be pretty much there.  If Kratos were fighting the Kraken, he would have scaled the beast's hide with his nasty hook blades and rammed Medusa's head straight into one of its eyes.  I'd much rather have watched that.  This is a series that's less about story and character and more about the things I like in mythology, namely, gods and monsters. 

Well, there you have it.  This rant has been weeks in the making, so I might as well just wrap it up and throw it out there.  Oh, and if anybody's wondering why I kept mum on the Silent Hill movie, it's simply because I'm not familiar enough with the games to know how far off course it goes... but it's a matter of record that I really like the movie. 

No comments:

Post a Comment