As Hollywood continues to pass over daring and original stories in favor of proven brand name properties, video games have rapidly become a regular source of popcorn fodder. Unlike the comic book superhero trend, which continues to chug along with no signs of stopping (and, in my opinion, continues to provide some pretty solid entertainment as well), video game movies are rarely successful enough to blossom into the franchises that studios hope they become, and are openly reviled by gamers and non-gamers alike. Sure, there are exceptions, but they are very few and far between.
The reasons should be fairly obvious to anyone who isn't a Hollywood yes man. A movie means removing the interactivity of a game, which instantly shuts off a huge part of what makes games work in the first place. Audiences have no control over what happens on the screen, and no control means less chance of any audience members bringing anything personal to the experience. There's no chance for choices, or exploration, or just plain fun vicarious ass-kicking; the results are often very dull and flat. Need examples? Let's look at Doom.
From its early PC days through its evolutions on various consoles (yes, I owned Doom 64), Doom has always been about creating an atmosphere of dread closing in on a single player weaving their way through a labyrinth that is one part space station and one part Hell itself. There's no real story, or character development, or even drama outside of the raw thrill of combat. And there's no need for it. The closest the games ever got to a real story was Doom 3, which fleshed out the details of the tragedy that drags a Martian colony into the very depths of Hell.
Badass! Now, if only they could pull that off in a movie... Oh wait, they tried. But here's the rub: take out the first person interactive experience, and what do you have? Not much. How do you pad out a two hour movie when the story can be summed up in a sentence? The answer for Revolution Studios was to add more characters. Audiences love characters, right? Unfortunately, the last thing Doom needs is a cast. What you get is a watered down version of Aliens with demons replacing the aliens, and haven't we seen that movie before? There's a reason the only good part of the movie is the brief first person sequence toward the end that emulates the gameplay:
That's it - you don't need to see the rest of the movie. That's the only good part. Seriously.
Now, not all games are as single-minded as Doom, and yes, it's true that games are becoming more and more cinematic. So adapting something that was originally designed to look like a movie should be a piece of cake, right? Well, yes and no. Resident Evil is a video game movie that should have been a no-brainer; the game has fairly simple premise, a straightforward narrative (I'm talking about the first game only - I'm well aware of how convoluted the story has become over the last several sequels), well-defined action sequences and the pacing and tension of an actual horror movie.
Yet somehow we ended up with a movie with no brain. Only the barest elements of the game's plot carries over into the movie. Zombies? Check. Umbrella Corporation? Check. People trying to survive? Check. But where's the mansion on the outskirts of Raccoon City? Uh, it's there, but it's just a secret entrance to a sprawling underground facility. Where are Chris Redfield and Jill Valentine, the two main characters? Uh, do we need them? Where is the nefarious Albert Wesker, the villain behind this whole outbreak? Uh, do we need him too? How about some people running around with guns killing zombies - isn't that enough? No? Ok, what if there's a sexy female character thrown in?
Somehow this movie launched a franchise that has fared pretty well. Each installment seems to try harder than the last to incorporate more of the elements that make the games so enjoyable, but there's still one major hurdle that keeps them from being good if not great: the character of Alice (Milla Jovavich). Alice is unique to the movies, and doesn't fit in with the game mythos at all. The harder the films try to shape the world of the games around this character, the weaker all of the material becomes, but at this point, she's married to the franchise (literally - she married Paul W. S. Anderson, director of the first and fourth films) and it's unlikely they'll ever ditch her to do things right. It's sad that it took two films to see Raccoon City overrun while Jill Valentine tries to outrun Nemesis, three films to see a Tyrant, and four films to see Albert Wesker in action. I'm pleased that this has become a successful franchise, but it kills me that it isn't as good as it could have been.
Yet even when video game adaptations stick pretty close to the material, they can still fail pretty miserably. Take Prince of Persia, a film I happen to like a lot, but which failed to find the audience it deserved. To me it had everything that makes the games fun (and keep in mind, the majority of my experience with the games has been as a spectator), and was a genuinely entertaining movie on its own. For reasons I still don't understand it was a flop, and it's unlikely we'll see another. And yet somehow there are no less than three Bloodrayne movies...
Which brings me to Uwe Boll. Here is a professional hack, a genuinely awful filmmaker who has built his career on ruining one video game adaptation after another. Anytime a major studio decides to gamble on a video game movie, I breathe a little easier once I confirm that Boll is not involved.
The other fundamental problem with video game adaptations is the casting issue. Many classic characters are classic because of their blankness and malleability. By attaching an actor to the character, a movie adaptation is walking a very fine line. One the one hand, they may find an actor that resonates with audiences, becoming synonymous with that character's name forever. On the other hand, they risk alienating the bulk of the character's fans by choosing the wrong person. Exhibit A:
Ok, so maybe that was unfair - there's a lot more than casting that's wrong about this movie. But casting Dennis Hopper as a giant lizard king is more than just a stretch.
Which brings me to the biggest pitfall of them all: adding, subtracting, and altering elements of the property until the film no longer resembles the property. Super Mario Brothers is probably the all-time champion when it comes to this folly, but let's not forget Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within. Series creator Hironobu Sakaguchi wrote, produced, and directed this lushly-animated but strangely lifeless sci-fi take on the material, stripping away the fantasy elements of mythological monsters, chocobos, and dungeons in favor of a hi-tech post-apocalyptic society at war with the ghosts of an alien culture. This was the debut of Square's animation division, which produced this film and one of the Animatrix shorts before folding. Everything that fans loved about Final Fantasy was thrown out the window in the hopes of reaching a wider audience with a more conventional sci-fi storyline, but by alienating the core audience, the film sealed its own fate.
Oh, and then there's the OTHER mistake - sticking with the source material to the point that you alienate any potential new audience. The Spirits Within isn't the only CG animated film to carry the Final Fantasy name, but it is the one that reached the widest audience. Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children is a direct sequel to the game... which is a great thing if you played the game. If not, you're just not going to watch this movie. The same can be said of Resident Evil: Degeneration, which is a much better RE movie than any of the Milla Jovavich films, but because it concerns characters from Resident Evil 2 and bridges the gap between RE 4 and RE 5, the chances that it will be seen by non-gamers are slim to none.
Is there a fair middle ground, a way to both placate the hardcore audience while attracting non-gamers to the multiplex? I'd like to think there is, but as we've seen, it's tricky, and you can't just pick a game because it's popular. Careful choices have to be made every step of the way... Here's a list of games that I think could work as films, and what it would take to make them work:
DEAD SPACE Isaac Clarke's first encounter with the Marker and the necromorphs it spawns was built on the foundations of Ridley Scott's Alien; is it so hard to reverse-engineer that success? The game has a neat, episodic narrative that can be easily streamlined into a two-hour adventure, while the game's most memorable elements - suspense, tension, atmosphere, and almost unbearable dread - are things that film excels at, and has excelled at for over a century. That said, there have been two direct-to-DVD films (both animated) that aim to expand and deepen the game's mythos; neither is terribly good. A cinematic approach would have to try hard not to overthink this one; the simplest tricks are often the most effective, and there's enough dramatic tension here between Isaac, his girlfriend Nicole, the other survivors of the rescue team, and the Marker itself to keep things moving. As Isaac spends the whole game behind a mask or helmet, casting is pretty open here.
BIOSHOCK Gore Verbinski has been campaigning for this for a while, but Universal backed out just as the project was starting to ramp up. This is a film that needs to be made, for the very simple reason that the story is fantastic and deserves to be experienced by audiences not necessarily familiar with the game. The introduction of an anonymous amnesiac survivor of a transatlantic plane crash to the fabulous underwater metropolis of eccentric industrialist Andrew Ryan would work just as well on film as it does in the game, if not better - audiences won't have to fiddle with selecting weapons and plasmids or hack vending machines to better their odds of survival. This is the kind of epic sci-fi storytelling that might benefit from removing the interactivity - the world of Rapture is a truly breathtaking place, and the story of the civil war that tore it apart is so beautifully realized and cleverly scripted that it can be enjoyed with or without a controller in hand. Verbinski apparently isn't the only party interested in making a Bioshock movie a reality; check out this recent trailer for a fan-made film:
DEVIL MAY CRY This is rumored to be kicking around over at Screen Gems (the same guys responsible for the Resident Evil films), but I've thought for a while there could be a good movie in here. The plots of most of the games are convoluted to the point of being incomprehensible, but this isn't the franchise for you if you're looking for plot. Originally devised as the other side of the Resident Evil coin, this series initially used the same static camera set up and even some of the same foley effects to tell a breathless action-driven story. It's all about flashy moves, over-the-top violence, and outrageous demon combat, and as each game in the series has become more cinematic, it's begun to look more and more likely that we'll see a movie one of these days (there's already a mediocre anime series). A few caveats: 1) Casting is crucial here. Whoever plays half-demon Dante has to be perfect or the whole venture will fall apart. Names aren't as important as ability and charisma - you need a dominating screen presence who can project Dante's infamous attitude. It may be wise to hold off until the upcoming "reboot" establishes the character's new look. 2) Keep it simple. Dante's struggle against his evil brother Virgil is probably the best storyline as long as it's streamlined. The fewer characters, the better - no need to bring in Nero or the women or the Jester or anything that will confuse or complicate matters. Keep it Dante vs. Virgil, revolving around their acceptance of their demon father Sparda and their human mother. 3) Keep the marketing focused on pushing this as an action movie with horror elements, not the other way around. Oh, and if anybody wants my two cents for a choice of director, Christophe Gans (Brotherhood of the Wolf, Silent Hill) has my vote.
GEARS OF WAR I'm just getting into this franchise, and I'm starting to understand what all the fuss is about. It's brutal, it's challenging, and it's often laughably cliched, but man, is it fun. With the high degree of brand recognition you can almost guarantee that a decent movie would be a hit. The story is basically a much rougher, nastier version of Starship Troopers, a hard-as-nails war story on a distant planet where hordes of indigenous lifeforms emerge from deep underground to wipe a human colony off their planet. It's not terribly original material, but if a movie can pull off the energy, smart design, epic scale, and tough guy banter, it could definitely work. Check out this short teaser trailer for the second game for a hint of just how narrow the gap between hit game and hit movie could be:
GOD OF WAR I'm dying to see a good mythological movie, especially if it's Greek mythology. I was raised on the old Harryhausen movies and can probably recite Clash of the Titans by rote. But just when it looked like I'd get my wish, with a remake of Clash and a Percy Jackson movie released the same year, Hollywood failed me again. Sam Worthington just isn't a very good action hero, and The Lightning Thief just plain sucked. My response to both films was to sulk and play some God of War. Hey, wait a minute... I'm not sure why some schmuck in Hollywood hasn't jumped on this one yet. How hard could it be? Hell, if you replaced Worthington's lame Perseus with a wrestler painted red and white, you'd be pretty much there. If Kratos were fighting the Kraken, he would have scaled the beast's hide with his nasty hook blades and rammed Medusa's head straight into one of its eyes. I'd much rather have watched that. This is a series that's less about story and character and more about the things I like in mythology, namely, gods and monsters.
Well, there you have it. This rant has been weeks in the making, so I might as well just wrap it up and throw it out there. Oh, and if anybody's wondering why I kept mum on the Silent Hill movie, it's simply because I'm not familiar enough with the games to know how far off course it goes... but it's a matter of record that I really like the movie.
Another Castle
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Wednesday, October 19, 2011
I Will Survive
Today I'd like to get into the spirit of Halloween by writing about one of my favorite game genres: Survival Horror.
Genre is a tricky thing to discuss these days, no matter what the medium. Look at movies: where once we had clearly discernible westerns, comedies, musicals, etc., we now have sub-genres and genre-mashups. How else do you explain films like The Warrior's Way, that numbskulled ninja western? Or let's take a more well-liked movie, like The Matrix. Sci-fi, martial arts, action, and more are crammed into a crowd-pleasing movie that mashes all its buttons at once. Don't even get me started on horror; there's classic, retro, exploitation, supernatural, slasher, Euro, body, psychological, torture... the list continues to grow as sub-genres swell and divide into new sub-genres.
Games are no different - in fact, they're even more complicated. What should the primary classification criteria be - the setting, the story, the gameplay? Super Mario Galaxy, Mario Kart, and Paper Mario all concern the same cast of characters, but are all radically different games - one is a platformer, one is a racer, and one is an RPG.
Fortunately for this post, survival horror is a very easily defined gaming genre. A term originally used to describe the game design of Shinji Mikami's beloved masterpiece Resident Evil, it points to a collection of core concepts. As the first word implies, the emphasis isn't on domination, but survival. Desperate escapes, sparse weaponry or ammunition, and fierce (and occasionally even indestructible) enemies. Item management is a crucial skill, and many games also incorporate at least a few puzzle elements. As for the "horror" part, well, that's the most malleable half of the equation (see my note about the horror genre in general above). Long story short, these games are meant to scare the pants off you.
I love these games. Within that seemingly narrow range of gameplay elements has sprung an amazing variety of horrors, some of them among the greatest gaming experiences I've ever encountered. Today I'd like to focus on a few of my absolute favorites.
RESIDENT EVIL 4 (Gamecube, PS2, PC, Wii, PSN and XBLA)
You can't get very far talking about survival horror without talking about Resident Evil. The first several games in the series followed a daring and ambitious concept - take the player through a horror film. The camera is static, and as your character walks in and out of the frame, the angles change. Part of what makes this series so much fun and so frustrating at the same time is that unless it's a second or third playthrough, you have no idea where that camera is going to move to, which makes moving around very difficult. But these games were never meant to be easy.
But my focus here is on the fourth entry of the series, which was controversial for a number of reasons and constituted a huge break in style and substance for the franchise. The first 3 games (as well as the Gamecube exclusive Resident Evil 0) dealt exclusively with the Umbrella Corporation's involvement with the outbreak of the experimental T-Virus on the outskirts of Raccoon City. The virus turns normal humans into zombies, while various test subjects (from monkeys to giant spiders to an enormous snake to the dreaded "Lickers") escape in the mayhem to make your life miserable. A follow-up game, Code Veronica, followed Claire Redfield (survivor of the second game and brother of the first game's hero) to an Umbrella facility on an isolated island in search of her missing brother. But with RE4, the powers that be decided that we'd had enough of zombies and it was time for something different.
This chapter follows Leon S. Kennedy, also a survivor of the second game, who has become a go-to guy for weird stuff happening. When a strange Spanish cult abducts the president's daughter, it's off to rural Spain. No zombies this time, but the inhabitants of the village Leon checks out are very hostile... and not quite human. An even bigger change than the weird parasite cult Los Illuminados was the gameplay, which switched to a mobile camera more or less permanently behind Leon, which tightened in to an over-the-shoulder look when aiming. This gave the game a more fluid action feel, while quicktime events and button mashing during the cinema scenes kept the game looking very pretty and cinematic but always engaging - you are afraid to set the controller down. But the biggest and most shocking change of all was that when it was released, it was exclusive to the family-friendly Nintendo Gamecube. Didn't stay that way, though - as sales continued to climb the game found its way onto PC, then PS2, than later down the line Wii, and now finally PSN and XBox Live, where it's been remastered in HD.
I'm currently playing it (AGAIN) on XBox, and you know what? This game never gets old. I've played it through so many times, so many ways, playing with all the weapons, earning all the bonuses, unlocking all the costumes, and you know what? I always just want to do it again. Capcom has usually been pretty generous with the bonus features, but RE4 goes beyond generous. Beating the game once unlocks Professional difficulty, one set of costumes, the Assignment Ada minigame (a short mission involving Ada Wong, another character carried over from RE2), The Mercenaries minigame, and in versions after the Gamecube original, a scenario called Separate Ways, which again features Ada Wong playing through stretches of the main game "behind the scenes" while Leon struggles to make it through his campaign. That's a ton of extra content, which means a lot of reasons to keep playing. Beating these extra games unlocks even more stuff, like crazy bonus weapons for use during replay.
RE4's legacy is another reason it makes my favorites list. While Resident Evil 5 was impressive, showing off next-gen graphics and continuing the story from RE4, it didn't pack quite as much fun, but that didn't stop other developers from adopting the gameplay design for their own games. The most famous franchise to mimic Leon's over-the-shoulder style is Dead Space, and my love for that series runs almost as deep as my love for the game that made it possible: Resident Evil 4.
CURSED MOUNTAIN (Wii)
When you think of gripping horror titles, few people think of the Wii. Like the Gamecube before it, Wii has developed a reputation as a family-friendly machine for "casual" gamers. But that doesn't mean there aren't hardcore gamers out there waggling their Wiimotes. Unfortunately, games for grownups are harder to find, and often slip through the cracks to become sleepers. Enter Cursed Mountain.
Before making their big action/RPG survival game Dead Island, developer Deep Silver played around with a different take on the exotic locale survival horror with this modest little Wii title. I just started playing this, so I'm not that far in, but I'm definitely intrigued. Players take the role of Eric Simmons, a career mountain climber who's traveled to the Himalayas in search of his missing brother Frank. Frank, it appears, decided to climb the sacred mountain Chomolonzo, and things haven't been right since he disappeared up the slopes. Something has interrupted the natural flow of death and reincarnation, and now Lhando, the highest city in the world and the starting point of your adventure, has become a city of ghosts.
As Eric makes his way up the mountain, he must find tools to help him fight off the ghosts and purify the lands he walks through. Various Buddhist monks, wisemen (and women), and prophets will help teach him pacification rituals (a lot of the combat involves gestures with the Wiimote and nunchuck) and add prayers to strengthen his ice axe, transforming it into a sacred spiritual weapon.
It's not a perfect game, but for $8 on Amazon (and that was for the Limited Edition in the steelcase with the making-of DVD and soundtrack), it was definitely worth it. The controls are a bit clumsy, and it's a slooooow game, but the premise has me hooked, and the atmosphere, the creepy music, and the unusual setting make for a pretty interesting experience. It's got more cool Buddhist demons, ghosts, and monsters than anything other than a Shin Megami Tensei game, and this is now the second game I've played (the first being the SMT title Digital Devil Saga II) that has taught me about the "perfect" mantra of "Om mani padme hm." I can't wait to find out what's waiting for me on top of the world.
CALL OF CTHULHU: DARK CORNERS OF THE EARTH (XBox, PS2)
So I'm a hardcore Lovecraft junkie, and when I heard about this game, I had to bite. I wasn't quite sure what to expect, and like Cursed Mountain, it's not a perfect game... but an interesting premise goes a long way, and I will always have a soft spot in my heart for this one.
The most interesting thing for me was that this game is essentially a video game adaptation of Lovecraft's short story The Shadow Over Innsmouth, which has always been my favorite. But rather than stop there, the folks over at Bethesda have woven in elements from The Shadow Out of Time and created a strange hybrid game that marries a creepy horror/adventure story with a first-person shooter mechanic, with uneven results. The controls are a bit clumsy, and the combination of investigating disappearances in rumor-shadowed Innsmouth one minute and blasting your way through hordes of Deep Ones the next is at times jarring, but being the Lovecraft fiend that I am, I couldn't resist things like this:
I've read the story so many times, yet it was such a thrill to be standing in the Innsmouth town square interacting with bulging-eyed Joe Sargent and his rattletrap Innsmouth bus that I couldn't believe it. Familiarity with the story came in handy later when I was ambushed in my hotel room at the Gilman House; fortunately I knew that my only means of escape lay in the connecting room and then out the window onto a nearby roof. Look at that, reading helped me play a video game. Ha! Then there were little surprises, like this:
Toward the end, the shooter part of the game pretty much takes over as you storm the secret lair of the Deep Ones beneath Devil Reef Doom-style, but I still loved it. This is a great example of how solid storytelling, terrific atmosphere, attention to detail, and a good hook can smooth over a lot minor gripes. Plus, it's probably the closest we'll ever get to seeing a Shadow Over Innsmouth movie.
ETERNAL DARKNESS: SANITY'S REQUIEM (Gamecube)
This sleeper was largely ignored on its initial release, but strong reviews and word of mouth helped build it into one of the most fondly-remembered games developed for Nintendo's "cutesy" Gamecube. A top-notch survival horror with a variety of intriguing locales, Eternal Darkness centers around the Rhode Island home of the Roivas family. As the last surviving member, you are tasked with piecing together the mystery that binds the bloodline to the house... which means that as you research heirlooms and unlock new parts of the house, you travel back along the bloodline to experience the cosmic horrors your ancestors have been fighting since the dawn of civilization. It all began with a Roman centurion lost in the desert, who found a strange temple containing three altars. The altar you approach will determine the cosmic entity that will become your primary adversary during the main game. One governs raw strength, one controls magic, and one tears at the fabric of sanity. Each member of this triumvirate has the power to cancel out another, in an eternal rock-paper-scissors. The centurion disturbs that equilibrium, and so the game is afoot.
The historical diversions take you all over the world and all across time, from the Mayan temples of South America to the cathedrals of France to the heart of the Iraq desert. Each trip down memory lane will improve your knowledge of the scope of the conflict as well as upgrade your talents, but be careful - the more you know, the less sane you are. Eternal Darkness is famous for its "insanity effects," moments where the game will pull the rug right out from under you. Let's watch:
Tee-hee! This game is seriously, seriously fun, but obviously not for the faint of heart. The sanity effects can really drive you nuts, especially the "Delete save data?" "Ok?" "Deleting Save File..." trick that will have you screaming and throwing things at the TV. The three deities give you three distinct paths through the game, encouraging replays. There's a deep magic system that encourages experimentation as you discover new runes that can be combined into spells. Some will fortify your sanity, some will sanctify your weapons for greater effect against monsters of a particular alignment, others can repair broken objects. Over the game, you'll have opportunities to wield a huge variety of weapons, too - and killing monsters is the best part of survival horror games, right? This sleeper hit is a real gem, one of the system's finest, most creative, most interesting achievements.
ALAN WAKE (XBox 360)
Saved the best for last.
I've been intrigued by this XBox 360 exclusive since it first showed up, but hadn't gotten around to playing it until now. I was completely unprepared for the unrelenting awesomeness that awaited me.
Alan Wake is a crime novelist who's been having a rough time lately. His wife Alice proposes a change of scenery and a little vacation, so they leave their NYC apartment behind and rent a cabin in the rustic mining town of Bright Falls, Washington. But Wake's troubles aren't about to desert him that easily. Before they've even settled in, Alice disappears, Wake regains consciousness in their wrecked car off a lonely forest road, and the cabin they rented has apparently ceased to exist. To make matters worse, Wake has lost a week of his life, obliterated from his memory, but keeps finding pages of a manuscript that he wrote but doesn't remember. He might be able to straighten some of this out if the locals would stop attacking him at night. Exuding an inky darkness, the possessed locals - hunters, foresters, fisherman - are known as the Taken, and before you can dispatch them (using the usual array of pistols, shotguns, hunting rifles, etc.), you'll have to burn off the darkness that protects them with some form of light. Most of the time Wake carries a flashlight, but flares, flashbang grenades, streetlights, worklights, and the like will work too.
Design-wise, this game is pretty incredible. Though the level design is fairly linear, it never looks or feels it; the woods stretch out pretty far, and there's no map. In the darkness (most of the game takes place at night) it's really easy to get lost and turned around in the woods, so you learn to rely on landmarks. It doesn't help that there are tons of collectibles hidden off the beaten path (manuscript pages, coffee thermoses, radios and TVs that have shows you need to hear and see). The detail to the world is nothing short of amazing, and while the floaty controls take some getting used to, the atmosphere, lighting, music, and story keep you riveted.
But even more exciting than the thrill of being stalked through the forest by creepy possessed woodsmen with little more than a flashlight and a pistol to protect yourself is the complex network of influences that make their way palpably into the game. The Pacific Northwest locale and cast of eccentric locals immediately bring Twin Peaks to mind (an idea reinforced by the fact that the game is split into episodes, each beginning with a "Previously on Alan Wake" recap), but the rabbit hole goes deeper than that. In the first episode, Roy Orbison's song "In Dreams" plays on a car radio, and again at the end of the episode. Anyone who's seen David Lynch's Blue Velvet can't help but shudder at the association. TVs frequently show reruns of an old show called "Night Springs," which is clearly a nod to The Twilight Zone. Episode Two ends with the song "Haunted" by Poe. Remember Poe? Of course not. She was a trip-hop singer in the mid-to-late 90s that faded into obscurity, but that song, and the album it came from, are companions to a novel called House of Leaves by Mark Danielewski (Poe's brother). The novel is a dense, convoluted, post-modern text about labyrinths, about getting lost in the abyss between reality and fiction, about a house that consumes the family and the life of a documentary filmmaker, who of course records everything that's happening. It's a brilliant but difficult work, one that I haven't thought about in years... until this game shook off the cobwebs through a simple association. Spooky.
In case it wasn't already plainly obvious, I LOVE this game. It has easily joined the ranks of my all-time favorites and I'm not even done yet (and there are two downloadable episodes, so I won't be quitting anytime soon). It's fun, it's scary, it's brilliantly designed, it's cleverly written, and the collectibles and achievements have me obsessed with getting EVERYTHING. Easily one of the most perfect games I've experienced, this is exactly the kind of game I had in mind when I started writing this blog - one that engages me on almost every conceivable level. Kudos to everyone at Remedy and Microsoft Studios for unleashing this awesomeness upon the world.
Well, that about wraps it up for this post. Sure, there are plenty of other survival horror games out there that I love, and even more that I've never played, but these are my favorites, so deal with it. In the meantime, here's a litte something to remind us all of our roots: the first survival horror game ever. I bought it at a yard sale for a quarter when I was in 4th grade. As I remember, it's pretty hard, too. The guy reviewing this is NOT me, by the way.
Have a safe and happy Halloween, folks - and don't stay up too late!
Genre is a tricky thing to discuss these days, no matter what the medium. Look at movies: where once we had clearly discernible westerns, comedies, musicals, etc., we now have sub-genres and genre-mashups. How else do you explain films like The Warrior's Way, that numbskulled ninja western? Or let's take a more well-liked movie, like The Matrix. Sci-fi, martial arts, action, and more are crammed into a crowd-pleasing movie that mashes all its buttons at once. Don't even get me started on horror; there's classic, retro, exploitation, supernatural, slasher, Euro, body, psychological, torture... the list continues to grow as sub-genres swell and divide into new sub-genres.
Games are no different - in fact, they're even more complicated. What should the primary classification criteria be - the setting, the story, the gameplay? Super Mario Galaxy, Mario Kart, and Paper Mario all concern the same cast of characters, but are all radically different games - one is a platformer, one is a racer, and one is an RPG.
Fortunately for this post, survival horror is a very easily defined gaming genre. A term originally used to describe the game design of Shinji Mikami's beloved masterpiece Resident Evil, it points to a collection of core concepts. As the first word implies, the emphasis isn't on domination, but survival. Desperate escapes, sparse weaponry or ammunition, and fierce (and occasionally even indestructible) enemies. Item management is a crucial skill, and many games also incorporate at least a few puzzle elements. As for the "horror" part, well, that's the most malleable half of the equation (see my note about the horror genre in general above). Long story short, these games are meant to scare the pants off you.
I love these games. Within that seemingly narrow range of gameplay elements has sprung an amazing variety of horrors, some of them among the greatest gaming experiences I've ever encountered. Today I'd like to focus on a few of my absolute favorites.
RESIDENT EVIL 4 (Gamecube, PS2, PC, Wii, PSN and XBLA)
You can't get very far talking about survival horror without talking about Resident Evil. The first several games in the series followed a daring and ambitious concept - take the player through a horror film. The camera is static, and as your character walks in and out of the frame, the angles change. Part of what makes this series so much fun and so frustrating at the same time is that unless it's a second or third playthrough, you have no idea where that camera is going to move to, which makes moving around very difficult. But these games were never meant to be easy.
But my focus here is on the fourth entry of the series, which was controversial for a number of reasons and constituted a huge break in style and substance for the franchise. The first 3 games (as well as the Gamecube exclusive Resident Evil 0) dealt exclusively with the Umbrella Corporation's involvement with the outbreak of the experimental T-Virus on the outskirts of Raccoon City. The virus turns normal humans into zombies, while various test subjects (from monkeys to giant spiders to an enormous snake to the dreaded "Lickers") escape in the mayhem to make your life miserable. A follow-up game, Code Veronica, followed Claire Redfield (survivor of the second game and brother of the first game's hero) to an Umbrella facility on an isolated island in search of her missing brother. But with RE4, the powers that be decided that we'd had enough of zombies and it was time for something different.
This chapter follows Leon S. Kennedy, also a survivor of the second game, who has become a go-to guy for weird stuff happening. When a strange Spanish cult abducts the president's daughter, it's off to rural Spain. No zombies this time, but the inhabitants of the village Leon checks out are very hostile... and not quite human. An even bigger change than the weird parasite cult Los Illuminados was the gameplay, which switched to a mobile camera more or less permanently behind Leon, which tightened in to an over-the-shoulder look when aiming. This gave the game a more fluid action feel, while quicktime events and button mashing during the cinema scenes kept the game looking very pretty and cinematic but always engaging - you are afraid to set the controller down. But the biggest and most shocking change of all was that when it was released, it was exclusive to the family-friendly Nintendo Gamecube. Didn't stay that way, though - as sales continued to climb the game found its way onto PC, then PS2, than later down the line Wii, and now finally PSN and XBox Live, where it's been remastered in HD.
I'm currently playing it (AGAIN) on XBox, and you know what? This game never gets old. I've played it through so many times, so many ways, playing with all the weapons, earning all the bonuses, unlocking all the costumes, and you know what? I always just want to do it again. Capcom has usually been pretty generous with the bonus features, but RE4 goes beyond generous. Beating the game once unlocks Professional difficulty, one set of costumes, the Assignment Ada minigame (a short mission involving Ada Wong, another character carried over from RE2), The Mercenaries minigame, and in versions after the Gamecube original, a scenario called Separate Ways, which again features Ada Wong playing through stretches of the main game "behind the scenes" while Leon struggles to make it through his campaign. That's a ton of extra content, which means a lot of reasons to keep playing. Beating these extra games unlocks even more stuff, like crazy bonus weapons for use during replay.
RE4's legacy is another reason it makes my favorites list. While Resident Evil 5 was impressive, showing off next-gen graphics and continuing the story from RE4, it didn't pack quite as much fun, but that didn't stop other developers from adopting the gameplay design for their own games. The most famous franchise to mimic Leon's over-the-shoulder style is Dead Space, and my love for that series runs almost as deep as my love for the game that made it possible: Resident Evil 4.
CURSED MOUNTAIN (Wii)
When you think of gripping horror titles, few people think of the Wii. Like the Gamecube before it, Wii has developed a reputation as a family-friendly machine for "casual" gamers. But that doesn't mean there aren't hardcore gamers out there waggling their Wiimotes. Unfortunately, games for grownups are harder to find, and often slip through the cracks to become sleepers. Enter Cursed Mountain.
Before making their big action/RPG survival game Dead Island, developer Deep Silver played around with a different take on the exotic locale survival horror with this modest little Wii title. I just started playing this, so I'm not that far in, but I'm definitely intrigued. Players take the role of Eric Simmons, a career mountain climber who's traveled to the Himalayas in search of his missing brother Frank. Frank, it appears, decided to climb the sacred mountain Chomolonzo, and things haven't been right since he disappeared up the slopes. Something has interrupted the natural flow of death and reincarnation, and now Lhando, the highest city in the world and the starting point of your adventure, has become a city of ghosts.
![]() | ||||
| This is about as close to civilization as you're going to get: a mysteriously empty city overrun by hungry ghosts. |
It's not a perfect game, but for $8 on Amazon (and that was for the Limited Edition in the steelcase with the making-of DVD and soundtrack), it was definitely worth it. The controls are a bit clumsy, and it's a slooooow game, but the premise has me hooked, and the atmosphere, the creepy music, and the unusual setting make for a pretty interesting experience. It's got more cool Buddhist demons, ghosts, and monsters than anything other than a Shin Megami Tensei game, and this is now the second game I've played (the first being the SMT title Digital Devil Saga II) that has taught me about the "perfect" mantra of "Om mani padme hm." I can't wait to find out what's waiting for me on top of the world.
CALL OF CTHULHU: DARK CORNERS OF THE EARTH (XBox, PS2)
So I'm a hardcore Lovecraft junkie, and when I heard about this game, I had to bite. I wasn't quite sure what to expect, and like Cursed Mountain, it's not a perfect game... but an interesting premise goes a long way, and I will always have a soft spot in my heart for this one.
The most interesting thing for me was that this game is essentially a video game adaptation of Lovecraft's short story The Shadow Over Innsmouth, which has always been my favorite. But rather than stop there, the folks over at Bethesda have woven in elements from The Shadow Out of Time and created a strange hybrid game that marries a creepy horror/adventure story with a first-person shooter mechanic, with uneven results. The controls are a bit clumsy, and the combination of investigating disappearances in rumor-shadowed Innsmouth one minute and blasting your way through hordes of Deep Ones the next is at times jarring, but being the Lovecraft fiend that I am, I couldn't resist things like this:
I've read the story so many times, yet it was such a thrill to be standing in the Innsmouth town square interacting with bulging-eyed Joe Sargent and his rattletrap Innsmouth bus that I couldn't believe it. Familiarity with the story came in handy later when I was ambushed in my hotel room at the Gilman House; fortunately I knew that my only means of escape lay in the connecting room and then out the window onto a nearby roof. Look at that, reading helped me play a video game. Ha! Then there were little surprises, like this:
Toward the end, the shooter part of the game pretty much takes over as you storm the secret lair of the Deep Ones beneath Devil Reef Doom-style, but I still loved it. This is a great example of how solid storytelling, terrific atmosphere, attention to detail, and a good hook can smooth over a lot minor gripes. Plus, it's probably the closest we'll ever get to seeing a Shadow Over Innsmouth movie.
ETERNAL DARKNESS: SANITY'S REQUIEM (Gamecube)
This sleeper was largely ignored on its initial release, but strong reviews and word of mouth helped build it into one of the most fondly-remembered games developed for Nintendo's "cutesy" Gamecube. A top-notch survival horror with a variety of intriguing locales, Eternal Darkness centers around the Rhode Island home of the Roivas family. As the last surviving member, you are tasked with piecing together the mystery that binds the bloodline to the house... which means that as you research heirlooms and unlock new parts of the house, you travel back along the bloodline to experience the cosmic horrors your ancestors have been fighting since the dawn of civilization. It all began with a Roman centurion lost in the desert, who found a strange temple containing three altars. The altar you approach will determine the cosmic entity that will become your primary adversary during the main game. One governs raw strength, one controls magic, and one tears at the fabric of sanity. Each member of this triumvirate has the power to cancel out another, in an eternal rock-paper-scissors. The centurion disturbs that equilibrium, and so the game is afoot.
The historical diversions take you all over the world and all across time, from the Mayan temples of South America to the cathedrals of France to the heart of the Iraq desert. Each trip down memory lane will improve your knowledge of the scope of the conflict as well as upgrade your talents, but be careful - the more you know, the less sane you are. Eternal Darkness is famous for its "insanity effects," moments where the game will pull the rug right out from under you. Let's watch:
Tee-hee! This game is seriously, seriously fun, but obviously not for the faint of heart. The sanity effects can really drive you nuts, especially the "Delete save data?" "Ok?" "Deleting Save File..." trick that will have you screaming and throwing things at the TV. The three deities give you three distinct paths through the game, encouraging replays. There's a deep magic system that encourages experimentation as you discover new runes that can be combined into spells. Some will fortify your sanity, some will sanctify your weapons for greater effect against monsters of a particular alignment, others can repair broken objects. Over the game, you'll have opportunities to wield a huge variety of weapons, too - and killing monsters is the best part of survival horror games, right? This sleeper hit is a real gem, one of the system's finest, most creative, most interesting achievements.
ALAN WAKE (XBox 360)
Saved the best for last.
I've been intrigued by this XBox 360 exclusive since it first showed up, but hadn't gotten around to playing it until now. I was completely unprepared for the unrelenting awesomeness that awaited me.
Alan Wake is a crime novelist who's been having a rough time lately. His wife Alice proposes a change of scenery and a little vacation, so they leave their NYC apartment behind and rent a cabin in the rustic mining town of Bright Falls, Washington. But Wake's troubles aren't about to desert him that easily. Before they've even settled in, Alice disappears, Wake regains consciousness in their wrecked car off a lonely forest road, and the cabin they rented has apparently ceased to exist. To make matters worse, Wake has lost a week of his life, obliterated from his memory, but keeps finding pages of a manuscript that he wrote but doesn't remember. He might be able to straighten some of this out if the locals would stop attacking him at night. Exuding an inky darkness, the possessed locals - hunters, foresters, fisherman - are known as the Taken, and before you can dispatch them (using the usual array of pistols, shotguns, hunting rifles, etc.), you'll have to burn off the darkness that protects them with some form of light. Most of the time Wake carries a flashlight, but flares, flashbang grenades, streetlights, worklights, and the like will work too.
Design-wise, this game is pretty incredible. Though the level design is fairly linear, it never looks or feels it; the woods stretch out pretty far, and there's no map. In the darkness (most of the game takes place at night) it's really easy to get lost and turned around in the woods, so you learn to rely on landmarks. It doesn't help that there are tons of collectibles hidden off the beaten path (manuscript pages, coffee thermoses, radios and TVs that have shows you need to hear and see). The detail to the world is nothing short of amazing, and while the floaty controls take some getting used to, the atmosphere, lighting, music, and story keep you riveted.
But even more exciting than the thrill of being stalked through the forest by creepy possessed woodsmen with little more than a flashlight and a pistol to protect yourself is the complex network of influences that make their way palpably into the game. The Pacific Northwest locale and cast of eccentric locals immediately bring Twin Peaks to mind (an idea reinforced by the fact that the game is split into episodes, each beginning with a "Previously on Alan Wake" recap), but the rabbit hole goes deeper than that. In the first episode, Roy Orbison's song "In Dreams" plays on a car radio, and again at the end of the episode. Anyone who's seen David Lynch's Blue Velvet can't help but shudder at the association. TVs frequently show reruns of an old show called "Night Springs," which is clearly a nod to The Twilight Zone. Episode Two ends with the song "Haunted" by Poe. Remember Poe? Of course not. She was a trip-hop singer in the mid-to-late 90s that faded into obscurity, but that song, and the album it came from, are companions to a novel called House of Leaves by Mark Danielewski (Poe's brother). The novel is a dense, convoluted, post-modern text about labyrinths, about getting lost in the abyss between reality and fiction, about a house that consumes the family and the life of a documentary filmmaker, who of course records everything that's happening. It's a brilliant but difficult work, one that I haven't thought about in years... until this game shook off the cobwebs through a simple association. Spooky.
In case it wasn't already plainly obvious, I LOVE this game. It has easily joined the ranks of my all-time favorites and I'm not even done yet (and there are two downloadable episodes, so I won't be quitting anytime soon). It's fun, it's scary, it's brilliantly designed, it's cleverly written, and the collectibles and achievements have me obsessed with getting EVERYTHING. Easily one of the most perfect games I've experienced, this is exactly the kind of game I had in mind when I started writing this blog - one that engages me on almost every conceivable level. Kudos to everyone at Remedy and Microsoft Studios for unleashing this awesomeness upon the world.
Well, that about wraps it up for this post. Sure, there are plenty of other survival horror games out there that I love, and even more that I've never played, but these are my favorites, so deal with it. In the meantime, here's a litte something to remind us all of our roots: the first survival horror game ever. I bought it at a yard sale for a quarter when I was in 4th grade. As I remember, it's pretty hard, too. The guy reviewing this is NOT me, by the way.
Have a safe and happy Halloween, folks - and don't stay up too late!
Sunday, October 9, 2011
Bundle Up! Repackaging the Past for Fun and Profit
Hey folks - long time, no blog. Been a bit preoccupied lately, but now I can hopefully get back into the swing of things. In this harsh economic climate, sometimes we have to sacrifice the big, shiny things and focus on getting the most value for our hard-earned dollars. With that in mind, I want to look at some recent and upcoming re-releases that do just that, and offer a more wallet-friendly alternative to gamers looking to feed their habits this coming holiday season.
Repackaging isn't exactly a new idea. How many of you have seen (or even owned) a Super Mario Bros. / Duck Hunt combo cartridge? Titles like Namco Museum and Intellivision Lives! are available for multiple consoles and offer a sweet way to relive some classic old school games. Fairly early into its lifespan, the original Playstation was home to the Final Fantasy Anthology collections, which spiffed up and repackaged those classic NES and SNES titles for those who were just getting started with the franchise with Final Fantasy VII. Of course, since I never had a Playstation and only bought a PS2 very late in its life cycle, I missed out on those great values and ended up shelling out for the DS remakes of FFIII and FFIV (both of which were well worth it, by the way).
Nowadays, this sort of budget repackaging has really kicked into high gear, and it's easy to see why. As cross-platform and backward compatibility issues are slowly disappearing, younger gamers now have opportunities to explore older "classic" titles without having to drag out some older console that might not even work anymore. My wife Jackie, never having had an N64, can now play the gorgeous, 3D-enhanced remakes of Ocarina of Time and Starfox 64 on the train (and, at last, get all of my "Do a barrel roll!" references). I can now play the entire Metroid Prime trilogy on Wii using the same controller without changing discs. It's a cool trend I'm glad to see picking up speed. Keeping in mind the philosophy that any game you've never played is a new game, I'm actually very excited this holiday to catch up on some long lost classics that for one reason or another I was never able to play before. Let's take a look at what I'm talking about:
That's not even close to being complete, but it's a good start. I pretty much stuck to just PS3 and Xbox, but there are package titles for Wii and TONS of classics available for download on each console's respective online networks. And with the much-publicized 10th anniversary remake of Halo on the horizon, this trend isn't likely to disappear any time soon. Which, in my opinion, is a good thing. Scratch that; a great thing. I can think of dozens of crazy packages and remakes that I would just die to own. For starters, a single-console Resident Evil box set would really be something, even if it were split into multiple archival volumes. I was never big on Halo but know tons of people who are - who wouldn't want a comprehensive collection? Or (and yeah, I'm really dreaming now) a collection of Rare's greatestN64 titles (Banjo-Kazooie, Banjo-Tooie, Conker's Bad Fur Day, Goldeneye, and Perfect Dark)? Hey Konami - can we get a Castlevania collection? PLEASE? Those were all such great games...
So that's a lot to take in, and I've only just scratched the surface. But consider this: if you bought every title on the above list, you'd end up spending about $250. For about that, you could pick up, say, Gears of War 3, Batman: Arkham City, Dark Souls, and The Legend of Zelda: The Skyward Sword. Four big holiday titles. If, however, you instead opted to invest that same amount on this list, you'd be scoring 17 full games. Think about that when you're shopping for the gamer in your life this season. Are they brand new games that all the cool kids are talking about? No. But for the most part, these titles have all stood the test of time and most have become classics in their respective genres. Any true gamer will tell you that all the spiffy new features and fancy visuals can't replace the joy of good solid gameplay, and a good game is a good game no matter how old and clunky it may appear to be. I can wait until next year for the price to drop on Batman; besides, I've got a ton of Gears of War to wade through right now. This winter I plan to pinch my pennies, bundle up, and spend some cozy time nestled by the fireplace enjoying some classics.
Repackaging isn't exactly a new idea. How many of you have seen (or even owned) a Super Mario Bros. / Duck Hunt combo cartridge? Titles like Namco Museum and Intellivision Lives! are available for multiple consoles and offer a sweet way to relive some classic old school games. Fairly early into its lifespan, the original Playstation was home to the Final Fantasy Anthology collections, which spiffed up and repackaged those classic NES and SNES titles for those who were just getting started with the franchise with Final Fantasy VII. Of course, since I never had a Playstation and only bought a PS2 very late in its life cycle, I missed out on those great values and ended up shelling out for the DS remakes of FFIII and FFIV (both of which were well worth it, by the way).
Nowadays, this sort of budget repackaging has really kicked into high gear, and it's easy to see why. As cross-platform and backward compatibility issues are slowly disappearing, younger gamers now have opportunities to explore older "classic" titles without having to drag out some older console that might not even work anymore. My wife Jackie, never having had an N64, can now play the gorgeous, 3D-enhanced remakes of Ocarina of Time and Starfox 64 on the train (and, at last, get all of my "Do a barrel roll!" references). I can now play the entire Metroid Prime trilogy on Wii using the same controller without changing discs. It's a cool trend I'm glad to see picking up speed. Keeping in mind the philosophy that any game you've never played is a new game, I'm actually very excited this holiday to catch up on some long lost classics that for one reason or another I was never able to play before. Let's take a look at what I'm talking about:
- I was thrilled when the God of War Collection gave me the option of catching up on two great titles reformatted for one console for only $30, so naturally I'm even more excited to be able to play the two PSP games in the series without having to play that GD PSP (for the record, neither Jackie nor I are fans of Sony's handheld, and only own it for titles like Crisis Core, Dissidia, Me and My Katamari, Persona, and of course, Work Time Fun). Even better, both games here have been remastered in HD and are available in 3D, should I ever opt for a 3D TV.
- These two games are legendary, and coming to the Sony console they were made for so late I never got around to picking them up (and Ico, being a very early PS2 release, isn't exactly a common find these days). Very much looking forward to rectifying that with this two-for re-release.
- Having watched Jack and her dad fight with these titles (not to mention each other) over the last couple of years, I think it might be time to pick them up and give them a try myself.
- How embarrassing - you know I've never played a Tomb Raider game? With this polished package, obviously intended to reintroduce Lara Croft, now a Square-Enix property, before the high profile reboot comes out next year, I'll finally be able to do something about that without too much difficulty. I can't wait!
- ! I played the original Metal Gear on NES, and Twin Snakes on Gamecube, but missed out on the rest of Snake's adventures (unless you count Super Smash Brothers: Brawl). This seems like a nice, affordable way to amend that... and do my eyes deceive me? Is that... for Xbox 360?!? It is indeed. At last I can shake off the tyranny of Sony and instead enjoy the tyranny of Microsoft! Ok, all I really care about is that this will help boost my Gamerscore (because, I'm afraid, I'm something of an Achievement whore).
- Achievement Unlocked: More Former Sony Exclusives on Xbox! Of all the embarrassing omissions in my gaming credentials, this is one of the worst, as I'm a sucker for survival horror. Resident Evil, Dead Space, heck, I'm even playing Cursed Mountain on Wii right now. While it's definitely a pity that the first game, for the original Playstation, isn't in this collection, these games are still tricky to find and I for one cannot wait to play them.
- I'm not a huge fan of shooters, but this series is probably one of the best-selling franchises for a reason. But why throw down $60 for the new game when I can spend less than half of that catching up with the first two chapters, with the added bonus of downloadable content thrown in? Like I said, any game that I've never played is a new game to me, and in the end, it's all about value. 2 1/2 games for $25? I finally couldn't resist; I just picked this up recently but haven't had time to play yet. I'll keep everyone posted.
That's not even close to being complete, but it's a good start. I pretty much stuck to just PS3 and Xbox, but there are package titles for Wii and TONS of classics available for download on each console's respective online networks. And with the much-publicized 10th anniversary remake of Halo on the horizon, this trend isn't likely to disappear any time soon. Which, in my opinion, is a good thing. Scratch that; a great thing. I can think of dozens of crazy packages and remakes that I would just die to own. For starters, a single-console Resident Evil box set would really be something, even if it were split into multiple archival volumes. I was never big on Halo but know tons of people who are - who wouldn't want a comprehensive collection? Or (and yeah, I'm really dreaming now) a collection of Rare's greatestN64 titles (Banjo-Kazooie, Banjo-Tooie, Conker's Bad Fur Day, Goldeneye, and Perfect Dark)? Hey Konami - can we get a Castlevania collection? PLEASE? Those were all such great games...
So that's a lot to take in, and I've only just scratched the surface. But consider this: if you bought every title on the above list, you'd end up spending about $250. For about that, you could pick up, say, Gears of War 3, Batman: Arkham City, Dark Souls, and The Legend of Zelda: The Skyward Sword. Four big holiday titles. If, however, you instead opted to invest that same amount on this list, you'd be scoring 17 full games. Think about that when you're shopping for the gamer in your life this season. Are they brand new games that all the cool kids are talking about? No. But for the most part, these titles have all stood the test of time and most have become classics in their respective genres. Any true gamer will tell you that all the spiffy new features and fancy visuals can't replace the joy of good solid gameplay, and a good game is a good game no matter how old and clunky it may appear to be. I can wait until next year for the price to drop on Batman; besides, I've got a ton of Gears of War to wade through right now. This winter I plan to pinch my pennies, bundle up, and spend some cozy time nestled by the fireplace enjoying some classics.
Saturday, August 13, 2011
You Knew This Was Coming: The Catherine Review
When I started this blog, it was largely to promote an idea: that games were the next logical step in narrative storytelling, and that through their interactive nature were potentially capable of delivering an unprecedented level of dramatic immersion. At the time, my quick-and-dirty example was the opening of Dead Space 2, which I found immediately more engaging, interesting, and vital than any horror film or novel I'd experienced previously. I also dedicated a lengthy post to The World Ends With You, a quirky handheld game that seeks to involve the player in every way imaginable - and succeeds beautifully.
Well folks, we have a new champion. Meet Catherine.
Catherine is a game that caught my attention from the sheer difficulty people had describing it. Published by Atlus and created by the same team responsible for the Persona games, Catherine plays like someone tried to combine a Joyce Carol Oates novel with Tetris. Let's start with the story.
Vincent, our protagonist, is a 32-year-old programmer who's been dating a woman named Katherine for about 5 years now. He's perfectly comfortable with the state of their relationship - he has the support he needs but also the freedom to kick back and go drinking with his pals whenever he wants. Katherine, however, wants more. She's tired of reunions with old college friends where she's the only one that's childless and unmarried. She's tired of not knowing where this relationship is going. She's terrified of where she will find herself if it falls apart. Wait... this doesn't sound much like a video game, does it?
The game begins with a quick introduction to Vincent and Katherine, then jumps straight to Vincent's recurring nightmare. In his dreams, Vincent (clad only in his pink polka-dotted boxers and sporting a pair of ram's horns sprouting from his head) must climb a crumbling tower of blocks, pushing and pulling blocks into place to form steps before the levels below him drop into the gaping abyss. To die here means to die for real, so you've really got to scramble. The sound of a tolling bell alerts you that escape is near, and once Vincent reaches the door, he awakes... to find that he's pissed himself in his sleep. Off to a great start.
Next up, a handful of cutscenes, where we see Katherine's concerns sour a lunch date, and then Vincent's growing uneasiness as he drinks with his friends at their favorite bar, The Stray Sheep. Soon, it's time for that last drink and stumbling home to pass out in bed. Thus begins Vincent's real descent into nightmare.
Vincent's nightmares form the core gameplay of Catherine but hardly define it. The first tower climb was a breeze, with very little to get in the way. This time, though, it's a longer, harder, crazier climb, populated with other dreamers (who appear as sheep) and, as the game progresses, traps, trick blocks, environmental hazards, and - in classic video game style - boss monsters. They can't really be defeated, only outrun. First up? A pair of disembodied giant hands wielding a fork.
The game really takes off when Vincent wakes up from this night's challenges and discovers he's not alone. Who's this girl (hint: it's the name of the game!) and where did she come from... and more importantly, what happened last night?
From here, the game goes in several directions at once. Much of what follows is animated cutscenes over which you have no control, but which are dictated by choices you make during the parts you can control. During the day, Vincent chats with his friends, or has lunch dates with Katherine, and eventually ends up back at the bar, where you can spend the night drinking (inebriation makes you more agile during the nightmare stages, so go ahead and drink yourself silly!), discussing your increasingly dire and worrisome woes with your friends, or wandering around the bar talking to other drinkers, many of whom you meet in sheep form in your dreams. They all have their private struggles, and finding out what landed them in the same nightmare might just be the key to helping you out of yours. Gradually, the choice mechanics are worked into the game - when Katherine texts you, you can choose from a selection of pre-written responses (or ignore her completely), but what makes it interesting is that your responses usually all communicate the same idea... but not in the same tone. Your responses can be apologetic, sympathetic, annoyed. Just like in real life, there's a world of difference between signing off with "Good night, Katherine" and "Bye." Navigating through these choices will impact a meter that occasionally appears, swinging the needle one way or the other. These tiny decisions will ultimately decide the end of the game (there are eight distinct endings), so choose well.
The rest of the game rapidly turns up the heat on Vincent as he struggles to find the right path. What do you do about this crazy girl who keeps winding up in your bed after you pass out? Is her name really Catherine? Do you tell Katherine about it? Do you just lie to her and continue seeing Catherine on the side? What do you do when you start getting threatening calls from Catherine's boyfriend? Wait, is it Catherine's boyfriend... or Katherine's?!?! Catherine is dropping Fatal Attraction hints that she'll kill you if you cheat on her; Katherine is dropping hints that she's pregnant. And lurking behind it all is a silent nocturnal killer that's knocking off people in their sleep...
There are so many things that make this game great it's hard to find a starting place. The balance between the frantic climbing puzzle stages and the slower, drama-oriented bar scenes is near-perfect. Just when you're sick and tired of pushing blocks and falling to your death for the 100th time, a well-climbed tower stage will clear and advance the plot to the next night at the Stray Sheep, where you can sit back and drink, focus on your friends and their problems, watch the news (usually reports about another young man - sometimes one that you know - being found dead in their sleep), fool around with the jukebox, or even play the arcade game "Rapunzel." There's plenty to keep you busy while you rest up and steel yourself for the next round of tortured climbing.
The puzzle stages are devious, with a wicked learning curve. There are frequent "landings" where you're granted a momentary respite, but even these have their dangers - to advance to the next climb, you'll have to enter a confessional and answer a question. How you answer affects your overall morality, but more importantly, they're tough questions. "If you suspected your lover of being unfaithful, would you confront them directly or reaffirm your trust in them privately?" Questions like this reach beyond the gaming space and touch the player's real life; who hasn't had to deal with issues like that in a relationship before? I'm no cheater, but Vincent's situation (at least the way I'm playing it) is sympathetic and miserable and may not even be his fault (I have my doubts about just how real Catherine is)... and a lot more suspenseful and engaging than just about any other game I can think of. I feel really bad for Katherine, and most of my decisions are attempts to keep Vincent's relationship with her alive. I'm gonna feel horrible if I can't save their love by the end of the game... Then there are the "boss stages," climbing stages where Vincent is pursued by some horrific representation of what's going on in his life. Katherine's giant hands stab at him with a lunch fork; a giant phantom baby that wants daddy to carry it; a zombie in a wedding dress screams for commitment. Oh yeah, and this thing really wants to play:
Which brings up another point - the sly, quirky humor. The morning after Vincent encounters the insatiable "Immoral Beast" pictured above, he again finds Catherine in his bed... hinting that last night's round of debauchery included a kinky "first" for her... Yeesh. Drinking enough at the bar and you'll be treated to some trivia about whatever it is you're drinking by a Shadoe Stevens-esque narrator whose dry delivery is nothing short of silly. Shoji Meguro, veteran composer of the Persona and other Shin Megami Tensei games (and, for the record, director of the recent PSP remake of Persona and the upcoming remake of Persona 2), decided that the music of Catherine should be just as offbeat and unpredictable as everything else in the game, and has provided a selection of bizarre arrangements of classical pieces for the nightmare stages. The idea was to include music that, like most things in dreams and nightmares, was simultaneously familiar and elusive... and Meguro succeeds tremendously. It's also pretty cocky to hear Handel's "Hallelujah" chorus when you clear a boss stage. The jukebox in the bar, on the other hand, plays a selection of Meguro's "hits" from previous games. Nice.
Now, I've been following this game all year, and have been increasingly interested and excited about it, so it should come as no surprise that I absolutely love it. Make no mistake, Catherine is not for everyone. There have been a lot of overwhelmingly positive reviews, but also a fair amount of disappointments. For some, the learning curve is too steep (I'm actually stuck about 2/3 of the way through; for the moment I've started over on "Easy" just to get through to an ending) and they get too frustrated to carry on; for others, the long, talky sequences get boring. But virtually every review agrees on one point: there's never been another game quite like it. And that's something that you don't hear enough of these days, so I'm not about to complain. In a lot of ways, this is my idea of a perfect game - it's involving, engaging, exciting, suspenseful, frustrating, extremely clever, and leaves the player with an overall experience unique to gaming. You can watch movies about adultery and read books about adultery, but playing this game is about as close as I want to get to the horror, tragedy, misery, and torture of the real thing - and that's actually an amazing accomplishment. Also amazing is the successful marriage of mind-numbingly addictive puzzle game with a strong narrative (not to mention a bold moral dimension). No matter how you look at it, it's not a game I will soon forget... or soon put down. Eight different endings... you really think I'm going to stop at one? Atlus has a reputation for delivering unique, unforgettable, and insanely challenging games (though they are still relative newcomers to the newer HD consoles), and this is another grand slam. I love it. And hate it. And love it some more.
Well folks, we have a new champion. Meet Catherine.
Catherine is a game that caught my attention from the sheer difficulty people had describing it. Published by Atlus and created by the same team responsible for the Persona games, Catherine plays like someone tried to combine a Joyce Carol Oates novel with Tetris. Let's start with the story.
Vincent, our protagonist, is a 32-year-old programmer who's been dating a woman named Katherine for about 5 years now. He's perfectly comfortable with the state of their relationship - he has the support he needs but also the freedom to kick back and go drinking with his pals whenever he wants. Katherine, however, wants more. She's tired of reunions with old college friends where she's the only one that's childless and unmarried. She's tired of not knowing where this relationship is going. She's terrified of where she will find herself if it falls apart. Wait... this doesn't sound much like a video game, does it?
![]() | |
| Katherine's got nothing to worry about... right? |
The game begins with a quick introduction to Vincent and Katherine, then jumps straight to Vincent's recurring nightmare. In his dreams, Vincent (clad only in his pink polka-dotted boxers and sporting a pair of ram's horns sprouting from his head) must climb a crumbling tower of blocks, pushing and pulling blocks into place to form steps before the levels below him drop into the gaping abyss. To die here means to die for real, so you've really got to scramble. The sound of a tolling bell alerts you that escape is near, and once Vincent reaches the door, he awakes... to find that he's pissed himself in his sleep. Off to a great start.
![]() | |
| It's like Jenga - you make steps by sliding blocks... just don't leave them unsupported! |
Next up, a handful of cutscenes, where we see Katherine's concerns sour a lunch date, and then Vincent's growing uneasiness as he drinks with his friends at their favorite bar, The Stray Sheep. Soon, it's time for that last drink and stumbling home to pass out in bed. Thus begins Vincent's real descent into nightmare.
Vincent's nightmares form the core gameplay of Catherine but hardly define it. The first tower climb was a breeze, with very little to get in the way. This time, though, it's a longer, harder, crazier climb, populated with other dreamers (who appear as sheep) and, as the game progresses, traps, trick blocks, environmental hazards, and - in classic video game style - boss monsters. They can't really be defeated, only outrun. First up? A pair of disembodied giant hands wielding a fork.
The game really takes off when Vincent wakes up from this night's challenges and discovers he's not alone. Who's this girl (hint: it's the name of the game!) and where did she come from... and more importantly, what happened last night?
![]() | |
| Uh-oh. |
The rest of the game rapidly turns up the heat on Vincent as he struggles to find the right path. What do you do about this crazy girl who keeps winding up in your bed after you pass out? Is her name really Catherine? Do you tell Katherine about it? Do you just lie to her and continue seeing Catherine on the side? What do you do when you start getting threatening calls from Catherine's boyfriend? Wait, is it Catherine's boyfriend... or Katherine's?!?! Catherine is dropping Fatal Attraction hints that she'll kill you if you cheat on her; Katherine is dropping hints that she's pregnant. And lurking behind it all is a silent nocturnal killer that's knocking off people in their sleep...
There are so many things that make this game great it's hard to find a starting place. The balance between the frantic climbing puzzle stages and the slower, drama-oriented bar scenes is near-perfect. Just when you're sick and tired of pushing blocks and falling to your death for the 100th time, a well-climbed tower stage will clear and advance the plot to the next night at the Stray Sheep, where you can sit back and drink, focus on your friends and their problems, watch the news (usually reports about another young man - sometimes one that you know - being found dead in their sleep), fool around with the jukebox, or even play the arcade game "Rapunzel." There's plenty to keep you busy while you rest up and steel yourself for the next round of tortured climbing.
The puzzle stages are devious, with a wicked learning curve. There are frequent "landings" where you're granted a momentary respite, but even these have their dangers - to advance to the next climb, you'll have to enter a confessional and answer a question. How you answer affects your overall morality, but more importantly, they're tough questions. "If you suspected your lover of being unfaithful, would you confront them directly or reaffirm your trust in them privately?" Questions like this reach beyond the gaming space and touch the player's real life; who hasn't had to deal with issues like that in a relationship before? I'm no cheater, but Vincent's situation (at least the way I'm playing it) is sympathetic and miserable and may not even be his fault (I have my doubts about just how real Catherine is)... and a lot more suspenseful and engaging than just about any other game I can think of. I feel really bad for Katherine, and most of my decisions are attempts to keep Vincent's relationship with her alive. I'm gonna feel horrible if I can't save their love by the end of the game... Then there are the "boss stages," climbing stages where Vincent is pursued by some horrific representation of what's going on in his life. Katherine's giant hands stab at him with a lunch fork; a giant phantom baby that wants daddy to carry it; a zombie in a wedding dress screams for commitment. Oh yeah, and this thing really wants to play:
![]() | |
| Yep, that's an ass-monster. |
Which brings up another point - the sly, quirky humor. The morning after Vincent encounters the insatiable "Immoral Beast" pictured above, he again finds Catherine in his bed... hinting that last night's round of debauchery included a kinky "first" for her... Yeesh. Drinking enough at the bar and you'll be treated to some trivia about whatever it is you're drinking by a Shadoe Stevens-esque narrator whose dry delivery is nothing short of silly. Shoji Meguro, veteran composer of the Persona and other Shin Megami Tensei games (and, for the record, director of the recent PSP remake of Persona and the upcoming remake of Persona 2), decided that the music of Catherine should be just as offbeat and unpredictable as everything else in the game, and has provided a selection of bizarre arrangements of classical pieces for the nightmare stages. The idea was to include music that, like most things in dreams and nightmares, was simultaneously familiar and elusive... and Meguro succeeds tremendously. It's also pretty cocky to hear Handel's "Hallelujah" chorus when you clear a boss stage. The jukebox in the bar, on the other hand, plays a selection of Meguro's "hits" from previous games. Nice.
Now, I've been following this game all year, and have been increasingly interested and excited about it, so it should come as no surprise that I absolutely love it. Make no mistake, Catherine is not for everyone. There have been a lot of overwhelmingly positive reviews, but also a fair amount of disappointments. For some, the learning curve is too steep (I'm actually stuck about 2/3 of the way through; for the moment I've started over on "Easy" just to get through to an ending) and they get too frustrated to carry on; for others, the long, talky sequences get boring. But virtually every review agrees on one point: there's never been another game quite like it. And that's something that you don't hear enough of these days, so I'm not about to complain. In a lot of ways, this is my idea of a perfect game - it's involving, engaging, exciting, suspenseful, frustrating, extremely clever, and leaves the player with an overall experience unique to gaming. You can watch movies about adultery and read books about adultery, but playing this game is about as close as I want to get to the horror, tragedy, misery, and torture of the real thing - and that's actually an amazing accomplishment. Also amazing is the successful marriage of mind-numbingly addictive puzzle game with a strong narrative (not to mention a bold moral dimension). No matter how you look at it, it's not a game I will soon forget... or soon put down. Eight different endings... you really think I'm going to stop at one? Atlus has a reputation for delivering unique, unforgettable, and insanely challenging games (though they are still relative newcomers to the newer HD consoles), and this is another grand slam. I love it. And hate it. And love it some more.
Friday, July 29, 2011
Hip to be Square...?
Howdy folks! A few posts ago I ended up writing an epic love letter to one of my favorite game publishers, the fine fellows over at Atlus. Today I'd like to look at the other side of the coin, my other favorite publisher... but one that has changed a lot in the past decade. And not necessarily for the better.
Yep, Square-Enix. One of the biggest publishers of the past 20 years, responsible for more than a handful of bona fide classics. I love 'em. And sometimes hate 'em. Let's take a look at why.
Before they were Square-Enix, they were known as Square (and Squaresoft). They started out as a small-time independent publisher in the early 1980s, but hit it big when they started developing for the Nintendo Famicom (known hereabouts as the Nintendo Entertainment System), and in a desperate gamble attempted to mimic the success of competitor Enix (who had scored a big hit with Dragon Quest a.k.a. Dragon Warrior) with their epic RPG title Final Fantasy. The rest, as they say, is history. Final Fantasy has become the dominant property in their portfolio, but they've since developed a pretty impressive collection of franchises, including Chrono Trigger/Cross, Valkyrie Profile, Kingdom Hearts, Secret of Mana, Parasite Eve, and Xenogears to name a few. They tried (and, rather spectacularly, failed) to start a feature animation studio. The original Square Co. has merged with former competitor Enix, and has more recently absorbed Taito and Eidos. But over the past decade, something has been slowly but steadily sliding downhill. Waits between games have become longer, new franchise installments never quite measure up to their predecessors, and they've even gotten into the bad habit of Hollywood-style cannibalism of remaking past glories and throwing out questionable spin-offs.
Take, for example, Final Fantasy VII. Far and away the highest-selling and most popular entry in the Final Fantasy franchise, FFVII was the first entry to feature 3D polygonal graphics and the first developed for a then next-gen console (originally for the N64 but refit for the Playstation). This was a game that sold consoles. It's a game that people still play, one that consistently makes all-time Top Ten lists. Then came FFVIII. Years and millions of dollars in development, it made money, but a lot of fans balked at the emphasis toward high-tech robots and guns in favor of the traditional swords and spears and monsters. FFIX went the exact opposite direction, delivering a very retro style... but again gamers were divided. FFX, the first to debut on the Playstation 2, found a good balance between traditional gameplay elements and the cutting edge technology at their disposal. It has its superfans and its detractors, but over the years has achieved almost the same status as FFVII. Things were looking good.
And then came FFX-2, the first direct sequel. I have yet to play this one, but I'm itching to see what's so bloody awful about it. It's famously bad - though I suspect it's not so much a bad game as a bad sequel, trading the near-perfect balance of the first game for new character designs and crazy gunplay. Huh?
FFXI was a massive online experiment that is still limping along, but I don't know a single person who's played it. FFXII created one of the deepest experiences in the franchise, but a weak story and lackluster characters hobbled it out of the gate. The Final Fantasy releases between XII and XIII paint a sad, desperate picture: Dirge of Cerberus, a 3rd person shooter starring FFVII's Vincent Valentine; Crisis Core, a PSP prequel to FFVII that delves into the origin of the eternal grudge match between Cloud and Sephiroth; DS remakes of FFIII and FFIV; PSP reissues of the Gameboy Advance remakes of FFI and FFII; a downloadable sequel to FFIV; and a couple of Chocobo games for the Wii (Chocobo's Dungeon) and DS (Chocobo Tales). Most recently we've gotten ANOTHER repackaging of FFIV, this time for the PSP (and including the downloadable sequel and an exclusive new chapter). Are we seeing a pattern here?
Now this is just Final Fantasy, which means it's just the tip of the iceberg. Kingdom Hearts has seen some similar releases, each straying further from the genius concept (Final Fantasy meets Disney) that started it, with Kingdom Hearts III just as mysteriously absent as the long-anticipated Final Fantasy XIII - Versus.
To add insult to injury, Square-Enix keeps expanding, having just snapped up Eidos. You may have noticed that the Square-Enix logo now appears on "Game of the Year" editions of Batman: Arkham Asylum, which is almost as weird as seeing them publish sequels like Kane and Lynch 2 and Just Cause 2. Now they'll be publishing the new Tomb Raider reboot (and have already repackaged and published a remastered collection of older Tomb Raider games). And don't even get me started on their toy company or manga publishing. The old RPG developer has its fingers in a LOT of pies these days.
So what's wrong with this? I understand this is a business, and the object of any business is to make money, but by absorbing so many properties and studios and dabbling in so many other businesses, Square has sacrificed its greatest asset: the feeling of playing a Square game. Square games used to be instantly recognizable - there was always a thoughtful balance of gameplay, style, and lingering post-game contentment in any release. Now there's just a glut of content, with no rhyme or reason. Compare them to my heroes over at Atlus; many of Atlus' releases are staggeringly unique, but all share the same dedication to quality and creativity, and even when they come from different developers and game studios, share a common stamp of quirkiness that goes hand-in-hand with being an Atlus release. But with Square, it's becoming more and more about franchise recognition, with some potentially great games getting criminally underdeveloped or undermarketed when they don't quite belong. Nier, for example, is a fantastic game that could have used a few more months of polish and bigger marketing push, rather than being released in the shadow of FFXIII. My beloved The World Ends With You, one of the most perfect games ever created, is not relegated to bargain bins. Next-gen titles like Infinite Undiscovery and The Last Remnant promised classic Square quality, but offered nothing spectacular or memorable. It was almost as though the eggheads at Square-Enix were putting all their eggs in one basket... but Final Fantasy XIII was in development so long that some of us almost stopped caring. But was it worth the wait? Was this really the game hardcore Square fans have been waiting for? Granted, the characters are much better than XII's, the graphics are jaw-dropping, and the amazing battle system is clearly the product of countless hours of tinkering and testing... but isn't there supposed to be a game in here too? Word around the campfire is that the upcoming sequel (yep, they're trying that again) will actually address most if not all of the complaints surrounding the first game, but it feels like too little, too late. I'm happy that Square-Enix is listening to their fans, but really wish they'd spend more time developing their own product (something they used to be legendarily good at) and less time schilling someone else's for a quick buck. (By the way, that "quick buck" resulted in Square-Enix recently posting a fiscal loss of roughly $150 million.)
I don't mind Square-Enix going after the big bucks. But I wish they would put more care into what they're selling. I'd probably be much happier if they created a separate arm that published games from other studios and dedicated the Square-Enix name to properties developed in-house. I guess what I'd like best is to see the company move back into a position where I see the logo and get excited, because I know there's something special waiting inside that package. The kind of feeling I used to get with this:
I miss those days.
Yep, Square-Enix. One of the biggest publishers of the past 20 years, responsible for more than a handful of bona fide classics. I love 'em. And sometimes hate 'em. Let's take a look at why.
Before they were Square-Enix, they were known as Square (and Squaresoft). They started out as a small-time independent publisher in the early 1980s, but hit it big when they started developing for the Nintendo Famicom (known hereabouts as the Nintendo Entertainment System), and in a desperate gamble attempted to mimic the success of competitor Enix (who had scored a big hit with Dragon Quest a.k.a. Dragon Warrior) with their epic RPG title Final Fantasy. The rest, as they say, is history. Final Fantasy has become the dominant property in their portfolio, but they've since developed a pretty impressive collection of franchises, including Chrono Trigger/Cross, Valkyrie Profile, Kingdom Hearts, Secret of Mana, Parasite Eve, and Xenogears to name a few. They tried (and, rather spectacularly, failed) to start a feature animation studio. The original Square Co. has merged with former competitor Enix, and has more recently absorbed Taito and Eidos. But over the past decade, something has been slowly but steadily sliding downhill. Waits between games have become longer, new franchise installments never quite measure up to their predecessors, and they've even gotten into the bad habit of Hollywood-style cannibalism of remaking past glories and throwing out questionable spin-offs.
![]() | |
| Glory days: 10 million copies sold... and counting. |
Take, for example, Final Fantasy VII. Far and away the highest-selling and most popular entry in the Final Fantasy franchise, FFVII was the first entry to feature 3D polygonal graphics and the first developed for a then next-gen console (originally for the N64 but refit for the Playstation). This was a game that sold consoles. It's a game that people still play, one that consistently makes all-time Top Ten lists. Then came FFVIII. Years and millions of dollars in development, it made money, but a lot of fans balked at the emphasis toward high-tech robots and guns in favor of the traditional swords and spears and monsters. FFIX went the exact opposite direction, delivering a very retro style... but again gamers were divided. FFX, the first to debut on the Playstation 2, found a good balance between traditional gameplay elements and the cutting edge technology at their disposal. It has its superfans and its detractors, but over the years has achieved almost the same status as FFVII. Things were looking good.
And then came FFX-2, the first direct sequel. I have yet to play this one, but I'm itching to see what's so bloody awful about it. It's famously bad - though I suspect it's not so much a bad game as a bad sequel, trading the near-perfect balance of the first game for new character designs and crazy gunplay. Huh?
![]() | |
| Questionable decisions: FFX's Yuna the Summoner became... |
![]() | |
| ... FFX-2's gun-toting pop star whore?!?! |
FFXI was a massive online experiment that is still limping along, but I don't know a single person who's played it. FFXII created one of the deepest experiences in the franchise, but a weak story and lackluster characters hobbled it out of the gate. The Final Fantasy releases between XII and XIII paint a sad, desperate picture: Dirge of Cerberus, a 3rd person shooter starring FFVII's Vincent Valentine; Crisis Core, a PSP prequel to FFVII that delves into the origin of the eternal grudge match between Cloud and Sephiroth; DS remakes of FFIII and FFIV; PSP reissues of the Gameboy Advance remakes of FFI and FFII; a downloadable sequel to FFIV; and a couple of Chocobo games for the Wii (Chocobo's Dungeon) and DS (Chocobo Tales). Most recently we've gotten ANOTHER repackaging of FFIV, this time for the PSP (and including the downloadable sequel and an exclusive new chapter). Are we seeing a pattern here?
Now this is just Final Fantasy, which means it's just the tip of the iceberg. Kingdom Hearts has seen some similar releases, each straying further from the genius concept (Final Fantasy meets Disney) that started it, with Kingdom Hearts III just as mysteriously absent as the long-anticipated Final Fantasy XIII - Versus.
To add insult to injury, Square-Enix keeps expanding, having just snapped up Eidos. You may have noticed that the Square-Enix logo now appears on "Game of the Year" editions of Batman: Arkham Asylum, which is almost as weird as seeing them publish sequels like Kane and Lynch 2 and Just Cause 2. Now they'll be publishing the new Tomb Raider reboot (and have already repackaged and published a remastered collection of older Tomb Raider games). And don't even get me started on their toy company or manga publishing. The old RPG developer has its fingers in a LOT of pies these days.
So what's wrong with this? I understand this is a business, and the object of any business is to make money, but by absorbing so many properties and studios and dabbling in so many other businesses, Square has sacrificed its greatest asset: the feeling of playing a Square game. Square games used to be instantly recognizable - there was always a thoughtful balance of gameplay, style, and lingering post-game contentment in any release. Now there's just a glut of content, with no rhyme or reason. Compare them to my heroes over at Atlus; many of Atlus' releases are staggeringly unique, but all share the same dedication to quality and creativity, and even when they come from different developers and game studios, share a common stamp of quirkiness that goes hand-in-hand with being an Atlus release. But with Square, it's becoming more and more about franchise recognition, with some potentially great games getting criminally underdeveloped or undermarketed when they don't quite belong. Nier, for example, is a fantastic game that could have used a few more months of polish and bigger marketing push, rather than being released in the shadow of FFXIII. My beloved The World Ends With You, one of the most perfect games ever created, is not relegated to bargain bins. Next-gen titles like Infinite Undiscovery and The Last Remnant promised classic Square quality, but offered nothing spectacular or memorable. It was almost as though the eggheads at Square-Enix were putting all their eggs in one basket... but Final Fantasy XIII was in development so long that some of us almost stopped caring. But was it worth the wait? Was this really the game hardcore Square fans have been waiting for? Granted, the characters are much better than XII's, the graphics are jaw-dropping, and the amazing battle system is clearly the product of countless hours of tinkering and testing... but isn't there supposed to be a game in here too? Word around the campfire is that the upcoming sequel (yep, they're trying that again) will actually address most if not all of the complaints surrounding the first game, but it feels like too little, too late. I'm happy that Square-Enix is listening to their fans, but really wish they'd spend more time developing their own product (something they used to be legendarily good at) and less time schilling someone else's for a quick buck. (By the way, that "quick buck" resulted in Square-Enix recently posting a fiscal loss of roughly $150 million.)
I don't mind Square-Enix going after the big bucks. But I wish they would put more care into what they're selling. I'd probably be much happier if they created a separate arm that published games from other studios and dedicated the Square-Enix name to properties developed in-house. I guess what I'd like best is to see the company move back into a position where I see the logo and get excited, because I know there's something special waiting inside that package. The kind of feeling I used to get with this:
I miss those days.
Tuesday, July 5, 2011
Music in Video Games: The Concert Experience
As most of my co-workers can attest, I listen to a lot of video game music. Part of it's nostalgia - I didn't watch much TV or really listen to the radio as a kid, so Metroid music fills in a lot of those warm fuzzy feeling gaps. And part of it's an honest appreciation for the genre (much like film music) - I can never get tired of hearing the "Gruntilda's Lair" theme from Banjo-Kazooie. But unlike most other forms of music, video game music can be a little challenging to enjoy and appreciate in groups, in a live concert setting. This post I'd like to look at two concert series that are attempting to amend that.
I recently had the pleasure of attending a concert that has eluded me for far too long due to its very selective touring cycle: Distant Worlds - The Music of Final Fantasy. I've been playing Final Fantasy games since, well, they started making them (I can still remember the shocking heft of the first NES title's 80-page instruction manual). The music for the first nine games was composed by Nobuo Uematsu, a rather ambitious fellow who's become something of a celebrity in the gaming world. Starting with the very basic 8-bit soundscapes of the NES, his music has evolved over the years as the technology has improved, but after a while it became clear that the sounds we were hearing on our game systems weren't always the sounds in Uematsu's head. For example, Final Fantasy VI (originally for the SNES) features a lengthy sequence set in an opera house, where the crew of main characters find echoes of their plight mirrored in the drama onstage. While the SNES was a MIDI-powerhouse at the time, it still didn't do opera justice, so the resulting scenes, while memorable, sounded a little weird:
One of the high points of the Distant Worlds concert was hearing the North American premiere of Uematsu's fully orchestrated and sung version of FFVI's "Draco and Maria" opera. Also on the program were memorable pieces from Final Fantasy I, II, III, IV, V, VII (the perennial favorite), VIII, IX, X, XI, XIII, and the upcoming XIV. Uematsu was present at the concert I attended, and his appearance provoked a standing ovation. Most of the pieces were accompanied by video montages projected on a screen above the orchestra.
These video montages were actually my biggest problem with the entire production. Some of them were good, and featured not just the sexy pre-rendered cutscenes from many of the later games but actual gameplay footage as well, which brought back a lot of fond memories. But many of them left one wondering. For the video accompanying the Chocobo theme, we saw footage from the largely chocobo-free FFVIII, along with a lot of repeated footage from II and XIII (the one where the chocobo chick lives in a character's afro), with a few shots of VII and X thrown in. Baffling, as FFIX has the most fondly remembered chocobo-related sidequests, and is also the game that features "Vamo alla Flamenco," a delightful Spanish guitar piece that was unfortunately played very poorly at this concert. Huh? And when we finally got around to "One-Winged Angel" (the theme of Sephiroth, the fan-favorite villain of FFVII, itself the fan-favorite game of the franchise), we saw very little of Sephiroth himself on the screen. Instead we got random footage from the CGI film Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children... but not the footage of Sephiroth. WTF?!?!
It's worth noting that "One-Winged Angel" was saved for last, and was preceded by a long gap filled with applause and fanboys screaming "ONE-WINGED ANGEL!" It's one of those pieces that every FF fan knows all too well, and audiences are apparently rabid for. Since the piece includes a chorus and there was no chorus present, the Distant Worlds team decided to try something clever: they had Nobuo Uematsu himself take the stage and conduct the audience (who pretty much all knew the Latin lyrics anyway) while the lyrics scrolled on the screen. An interesting idea, and a lot of fun, but next to nobody in that room knew how to sing.
All in all, it was a fine show, though for such a high-profile affair (they've been touring this concert for years, in apparently every city BUT New York) there were way too many flubs (the videos were very disappointing) and that Spanish guitar soloist should be dismissed.
If the Distant Worlds concert felt like video games getting dressed up and going to the opera, then my other video game concert experience, Video Games Live, was like a gamer's Lollapalooza. Jackie and I attended this on our first anniversary, and I loved every minute of it.
Video Games Live was created and hosted by Jack Wall and Tommy Tallarico, both musicians and specifically game composers who felt that their line of work needed an outlet where it could be celebrated for all the joy and happiness it brings. They started small but have turned their little idea into an almost full-time obsession that has attracted a traveling company of musicians and gamers and become quite the festive romp.
We had no idea what to expect when we arrived, but it didn't take long to guess what we were in for. The place was packed with geeks and gamers, half of which looked ready for a convention. Cosplayers were everywhere, and there was even a Guitar Hero challenge going on in the lobby before the show. When the lights finally dimmed and the show started, I found myself amazed at the variety of amusements and the sheer energy level of the whole production. Jackie was annoyed that Tommy Tallarico talked so much, but as the ringleader of this mad musical circus, he kind of had to - he would stop to introduce solo performers, talk about the history of the project and how it had snowballed into what it was now, and give a bit of background about the games whose music they were performing. There were also interruptions like a costume contest and a few video shorts like this one:
But of course, we came for the music, and the music was wonderfully played... and wonderfully diverse. We heard Halo. We heard Kingdom Hearts. We heard World of Warcraft. We heard Mega Man. My favorite moments involved the solo performers. First up was Martin Leung, who performed a piano medley of Final Fantasy tunes as well some classic selections from Tetris and Super Mario World. Here's a clip of Martin doing his thing:
Tallarico and Wall apparently discovered Martin on YouTube... which is also where they found Laura Intravia, better known as "Flute Link." Laura apparently developed this little bit for conventions but his since found bigger audiences for her geek talents. Those familiar with Ocarina of Time will have no trouble identifying these tunes:
Throughout the show we were treated to plenty of visual aids on the triptych of big screens. Blizzard was very kind to supply a LOT of footage for the Warcraft suite, and Tallarico and Wall managed to get license clearances for a lot of actual gameplay footage. Only guess who didn't play nice - SQUARE-ENIX, publisher of the Final Fantasy series. Maybe because they hold one of the only competing events? Any Square-Enix music performed yielded a slideshow of cosplay pictures and fan art, which was actually a lot better than what Square-Enix did with Distant Worlds.
Not surprisingly, there was an encore. And what do you think members of the crowd were clamoring for when Tallarico and company came back out? That's right - "One-Winged Angel." I'm beginning to believe it's the "Freebird" of gamer culture. Check out the energy in the Video Games Live version as compared to Distant Worlds:
Anyhow, it was a wild and wondrous romp, a real multifaceted celebration of gaming culture - both the artists that make these games (and their music) possible and the fans that support them and let them keep creating. There was so much energy and so much love it was almost impossible to not get caught up in it. Video Games Live is still touring, and their show is always changing, so I can't wait to see them again. Maybe they'll do some Banjo-Kazooie! Or better yet, a tribute to all those great Rare scores from the N64 days (you heard me - get some Jet Force Gemini in there!). Or some Resident Evil! How about some Dead Space! I could go on and on and on... and I hope these guys do too.
I recently had the pleasure of attending a concert that has eluded me for far too long due to its very selective touring cycle: Distant Worlds - The Music of Final Fantasy. I've been playing Final Fantasy games since, well, they started making them (I can still remember the shocking heft of the first NES title's 80-page instruction manual). The music for the first nine games was composed by Nobuo Uematsu, a rather ambitious fellow who's become something of a celebrity in the gaming world. Starting with the very basic 8-bit soundscapes of the NES, his music has evolved over the years as the technology has improved, but after a while it became clear that the sounds we were hearing on our game systems weren't always the sounds in Uematsu's head. For example, Final Fantasy VI (originally for the SNES) features a lengthy sequence set in an opera house, where the crew of main characters find echoes of their plight mirrored in the drama onstage. While the SNES was a MIDI-powerhouse at the time, it still didn't do opera justice, so the resulting scenes, while memorable, sounded a little weird:
One of the high points of the Distant Worlds concert was hearing the North American premiere of Uematsu's fully orchestrated and sung version of FFVI's "Draco and Maria" opera. Also on the program were memorable pieces from Final Fantasy I, II, III, IV, V, VII (the perennial favorite), VIII, IX, X, XI, XIII, and the upcoming XIV. Uematsu was present at the concert I attended, and his appearance provoked a standing ovation. Most of the pieces were accompanied by video montages projected on a screen above the orchestra.
These video montages were actually my biggest problem with the entire production. Some of them were good, and featured not just the sexy pre-rendered cutscenes from many of the later games but actual gameplay footage as well, which brought back a lot of fond memories. But many of them left one wondering. For the video accompanying the Chocobo theme, we saw footage from the largely chocobo-free FFVIII, along with a lot of repeated footage from II and XIII (the one where the chocobo chick lives in a character's afro), with a few shots of VII and X thrown in. Baffling, as FFIX has the most fondly remembered chocobo-related sidequests, and is also the game that features "Vamo alla Flamenco," a delightful Spanish guitar piece that was unfortunately played very poorly at this concert. Huh? And when we finally got around to "One-Winged Angel" (the theme of Sephiroth, the fan-favorite villain of FFVII, itself the fan-favorite game of the franchise), we saw very little of Sephiroth himself on the screen. Instead we got random footage from the CGI film Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children... but not the footage of Sephiroth. WTF?!?!
It's worth noting that "One-Winged Angel" was saved for last, and was preceded by a long gap filled with applause and fanboys screaming "ONE-WINGED ANGEL!" It's one of those pieces that every FF fan knows all too well, and audiences are apparently rabid for. Since the piece includes a chorus and there was no chorus present, the Distant Worlds team decided to try something clever: they had Nobuo Uematsu himself take the stage and conduct the audience (who pretty much all knew the Latin lyrics anyway) while the lyrics scrolled on the screen. An interesting idea, and a lot of fun, but next to nobody in that room knew how to sing.
All in all, it was a fine show, though for such a high-profile affair (they've been touring this concert for years, in apparently every city BUT New York) there were way too many flubs (the videos were very disappointing) and that Spanish guitar soloist should be dismissed.
If the Distant Worlds concert felt like video games getting dressed up and going to the opera, then my other video game concert experience, Video Games Live, was like a gamer's Lollapalooza. Jackie and I attended this on our first anniversary, and I loved every minute of it.
Video Games Live was created and hosted by Jack Wall and Tommy Tallarico, both musicians and specifically game composers who felt that their line of work needed an outlet where it could be celebrated for all the joy and happiness it brings. They started small but have turned their little idea into an almost full-time obsession that has attracted a traveling company of musicians and gamers and become quite the festive romp.
We had no idea what to expect when we arrived, but it didn't take long to guess what we were in for. The place was packed with geeks and gamers, half of which looked ready for a convention. Cosplayers were everywhere, and there was even a Guitar Hero challenge going on in the lobby before the show. When the lights finally dimmed and the show started, I found myself amazed at the variety of amusements and the sheer energy level of the whole production. Jackie was annoyed that Tommy Tallarico talked so much, but as the ringleader of this mad musical circus, he kind of had to - he would stop to introduce solo performers, talk about the history of the project and how it had snowballed into what it was now, and give a bit of background about the games whose music they were performing. There were also interruptions like a costume contest and a few video shorts like this one:
But of course, we came for the music, and the music was wonderfully played... and wonderfully diverse. We heard Halo. We heard Kingdom Hearts. We heard World of Warcraft. We heard Mega Man. My favorite moments involved the solo performers. First up was Martin Leung, who performed a piano medley of Final Fantasy tunes as well some classic selections from Tetris and Super Mario World. Here's a clip of Martin doing his thing:
Tallarico and Wall apparently discovered Martin on YouTube... which is also where they found Laura Intravia, better known as "Flute Link." Laura apparently developed this little bit for conventions but his since found bigger audiences for her geek talents. Those familiar with Ocarina of Time will have no trouble identifying these tunes:
Throughout the show we were treated to plenty of visual aids on the triptych of big screens. Blizzard was very kind to supply a LOT of footage for the Warcraft suite, and Tallarico and Wall managed to get license clearances for a lot of actual gameplay footage. Only guess who didn't play nice - SQUARE-ENIX, publisher of the Final Fantasy series. Maybe because they hold one of the only competing events? Any Square-Enix music performed yielded a slideshow of cosplay pictures and fan art, which was actually a lot better than what Square-Enix did with Distant Worlds.
Not surprisingly, there was an encore. And what do you think members of the crowd were clamoring for when Tallarico and company came back out? That's right - "One-Winged Angel." I'm beginning to believe it's the "Freebird" of gamer culture. Check out the energy in the Video Games Live version as compared to Distant Worlds:
Anyhow, it was a wild and wondrous romp, a real multifaceted celebration of gaming culture - both the artists that make these games (and their music) possible and the fans that support them and let them keep creating. There was so much energy and so much love it was almost impossible to not get caught up in it. Video Games Live is still touring, and their show is always changing, so I can't wait to see them again. Maybe they'll do some Banjo-Kazooie! Or better yet, a tribute to all those great Rare scores from the N64 days (you heard me - get some Jet Force Gemini in there!). Or some Resident Evil! How about some Dead Space! I could go on and on and on... and I hope these guys do too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)































