Well folks, we have a new champion. Meet Catherine.
Catherine is a game that caught my attention from the sheer difficulty people had describing it. Published by Atlus and created by the same team responsible for the Persona games, Catherine plays like someone tried to combine a Joyce Carol Oates novel with Tetris. Let's start with the story.
Vincent, our protagonist, is a 32-year-old programmer who's been dating a woman named Katherine for about 5 years now. He's perfectly comfortable with the state of their relationship - he has the support he needs but also the freedom to kick back and go drinking with his pals whenever he wants. Katherine, however, wants more. She's tired of reunions with old college friends where she's the only one that's childless and unmarried. She's tired of not knowing where this relationship is going. She's terrified of where she will find herself if it falls apart. Wait... this doesn't sound much like a video game, does it?
![]() | |
| Katherine's got nothing to worry about... right? |
The game begins with a quick introduction to Vincent and Katherine, then jumps straight to Vincent's recurring nightmare. In his dreams, Vincent (clad only in his pink polka-dotted boxers and sporting a pair of ram's horns sprouting from his head) must climb a crumbling tower of blocks, pushing and pulling blocks into place to form steps before the levels below him drop into the gaping abyss. To die here means to die for real, so you've really got to scramble. The sound of a tolling bell alerts you that escape is near, and once Vincent reaches the door, he awakes... to find that he's pissed himself in his sleep. Off to a great start.
![]() | |
| It's like Jenga - you make steps by sliding blocks... just don't leave them unsupported! |
Next up, a handful of cutscenes, where we see Katherine's concerns sour a lunch date, and then Vincent's growing uneasiness as he drinks with his friends at their favorite bar, The Stray Sheep. Soon, it's time for that last drink and stumbling home to pass out in bed. Thus begins Vincent's real descent into nightmare.
Vincent's nightmares form the core gameplay of Catherine but hardly define it. The first tower climb was a breeze, with very little to get in the way. This time, though, it's a longer, harder, crazier climb, populated with other dreamers (who appear as sheep) and, as the game progresses, traps, trick blocks, environmental hazards, and - in classic video game style - boss monsters. They can't really be defeated, only outrun. First up? A pair of disembodied giant hands wielding a fork.
The game really takes off when Vincent wakes up from this night's challenges and discovers he's not alone. Who's this girl (hint: it's the name of the game!) and where did she come from... and more importantly, what happened last night?
![]() | |
| Uh-oh. |
The rest of the game rapidly turns up the heat on Vincent as he struggles to find the right path. What do you do about this crazy girl who keeps winding up in your bed after you pass out? Is her name really Catherine? Do you tell Katherine about it? Do you just lie to her and continue seeing Catherine on the side? What do you do when you start getting threatening calls from Catherine's boyfriend? Wait, is it Catherine's boyfriend... or Katherine's?!?! Catherine is dropping Fatal Attraction hints that she'll kill you if you cheat on her; Katherine is dropping hints that she's pregnant. And lurking behind it all is a silent nocturnal killer that's knocking off people in their sleep...
There are so many things that make this game great it's hard to find a starting place. The balance between the frantic climbing puzzle stages and the slower, drama-oriented bar scenes is near-perfect. Just when you're sick and tired of pushing blocks and falling to your death for the 100th time, a well-climbed tower stage will clear and advance the plot to the next night at the Stray Sheep, where you can sit back and drink, focus on your friends and their problems, watch the news (usually reports about another young man - sometimes one that you know - being found dead in their sleep), fool around with the jukebox, or even play the arcade game "Rapunzel." There's plenty to keep you busy while you rest up and steel yourself for the next round of tortured climbing.
The puzzle stages are devious, with a wicked learning curve. There are frequent "landings" where you're granted a momentary respite, but even these have their dangers - to advance to the next climb, you'll have to enter a confessional and answer a question. How you answer affects your overall morality, but more importantly, they're tough questions. "If you suspected your lover of being unfaithful, would you confront them directly or reaffirm your trust in them privately?" Questions like this reach beyond the gaming space and touch the player's real life; who hasn't had to deal with issues like that in a relationship before? I'm no cheater, but Vincent's situation (at least the way I'm playing it) is sympathetic and miserable and may not even be his fault (I have my doubts about just how real Catherine is)... and a lot more suspenseful and engaging than just about any other game I can think of. I feel really bad for Katherine, and most of my decisions are attempts to keep Vincent's relationship with her alive. I'm gonna feel horrible if I can't save their love by the end of the game... Then there are the "boss stages," climbing stages where Vincent is pursued by some horrific representation of what's going on in his life. Katherine's giant hands stab at him with a lunch fork; a giant phantom baby that wants daddy to carry it; a zombie in a wedding dress screams for commitment. Oh yeah, and this thing really wants to play:
![]() | |
| Yep, that's an ass-monster. |
Which brings up another point - the sly, quirky humor. The morning after Vincent encounters the insatiable "Immoral Beast" pictured above, he again finds Catherine in his bed... hinting that last night's round of debauchery included a kinky "first" for her... Yeesh. Drinking enough at the bar and you'll be treated to some trivia about whatever it is you're drinking by a Shadoe Stevens-esque narrator whose dry delivery is nothing short of silly. Shoji Meguro, veteran composer of the Persona and other Shin Megami Tensei games (and, for the record, director of the recent PSP remake of Persona and the upcoming remake of Persona 2), decided that the music of Catherine should be just as offbeat and unpredictable as everything else in the game, and has provided a selection of bizarre arrangements of classical pieces for the nightmare stages. The idea was to include music that, like most things in dreams and nightmares, was simultaneously familiar and elusive... and Meguro succeeds tremendously. It's also pretty cocky to hear Handel's "Hallelujah" chorus when you clear a boss stage. The jukebox in the bar, on the other hand, plays a selection of Meguro's "hits" from previous games. Nice.
Now, I've been following this game all year, and have been increasingly interested and excited about it, so it should come as no surprise that I absolutely love it. Make no mistake, Catherine is not for everyone. There have been a lot of overwhelmingly positive reviews, but also a fair amount of disappointments. For some, the learning curve is too steep (I'm actually stuck about 2/3 of the way through; for the moment I've started over on "Easy" just to get through to an ending) and they get too frustrated to carry on; for others, the long, talky sequences get boring. But virtually every review agrees on one point: there's never been another game quite like it. And that's something that you don't hear enough of these days, so I'm not about to complain. In a lot of ways, this is my idea of a perfect game - it's involving, engaging, exciting, suspenseful, frustrating, extremely clever, and leaves the player with an overall experience unique to gaming. You can watch movies about adultery and read books about adultery, but playing this game is about as close as I want to get to the horror, tragedy, misery, and torture of the real thing - and that's actually an amazing accomplishment. Also amazing is the successful marriage of mind-numbingly addictive puzzle game with a strong narrative (not to mention a bold moral dimension). No matter how you look at it, it's not a game I will soon forget... or soon put down. Eight different endings... you really think I'm going to stop at one? Atlus has a reputation for delivering unique, unforgettable, and insanely challenging games (though they are still relative newcomers to the newer HD consoles), and this is another grand slam. I love it. And hate it. And love it some more.





