Friday, July 29, 2011

Hip to be Square...?

Howdy folks!  A few posts ago I ended up writing an epic love letter to one of my favorite game publishers, the fine fellows over at Atlus.  Today I'd like to look at the other side of the coin, my other favorite publisher... but one that has changed a lot in the past decade.  And not necessarily for the better.


Yep, Square-Enix.  One of the biggest publishers of the past 20 years, responsible for more than a handful of bona fide classics.  I love 'em.  And sometimes hate 'em.  Let's take a look at why.

Before they were Square-Enix, they were known as Square (and Squaresoft).  They started out as a small-time independent publisher in the early 1980s, but hit it big when they started developing for the Nintendo Famicom (known hereabouts as the Nintendo Entertainment System), and in a desperate gamble attempted to mimic the success of competitor Enix (who had scored a big hit with Dragon Quest a.k.a. Dragon Warrior) with their epic RPG title Final Fantasy.  The rest, as they say, is history.  Final Fantasy has become the dominant property in their portfolio, but they've since developed a pretty impressive collection of franchises, including Chrono Trigger/Cross, Valkyrie Profile, Kingdom Hearts, Secret of Mana, Parasite Eve, and Xenogears to name a few.  They tried (and, rather spectacularly, failed) to start a feature animation studio.  The original Square Co. has merged with former competitor Enix, and has more recently absorbed Taito and Eidos.  But over the past decade, something has been slowly but steadily sliding downhill.  Waits between games have become longer, new franchise installments never quite measure up to their predecessors, and they've even gotten into the bad habit of Hollywood-style cannibalism of remaking past glories and throwing out questionable spin-offs.

Glory days:  10 million copies sold... and counting.


Take, for example, Final Fantasy VII.  Far and away the highest-selling and most popular entry in the Final Fantasy franchise, FFVII was the first entry to feature 3D polygonal graphics and the first developed for a then next-gen console (originally for the N64 but refit for the Playstation).  This was a game that sold consoles.  It's a game that people still play, one that consistently makes all-time Top Ten lists.  Then came FFVIII.  Years and millions of dollars in development, it made money, but a lot of fans balked at the emphasis toward high-tech robots and guns in favor of the traditional swords and spears and monsters.  FFIX went the exact opposite direction, delivering a very retro style... but again gamers were divided.  FFX, the first to debut on the Playstation 2, found a good balance between traditional gameplay elements and the cutting edge technology at their disposal.  It has its superfans and its detractors, but over the years has achieved almost the same status as FFVII.  Things were looking good.

And then came FFX-2, the first direct sequel.  I have yet to play this one, but I'm itching to see what's so bloody awful about it.  It's famously bad - though I suspect it's not so much a bad game as a bad sequel, trading the near-perfect balance of the first game for new character designs and crazy gunplay.  Huh?

Questionable decisions:  FFX's Yuna the Summoner became...

... FFX-2's gun-toting pop star whore?!?!

FFXI was a massive online experiment that is still limping along, but I don't know a single person who's played it.  FFXII created one of the deepest experiences in the franchise, but a weak story and lackluster characters hobbled it out of the gate.  The Final Fantasy releases between XII and XIII paint a sad, desperate picture: Dirge of Cerberus, a 3rd person shooter starring FFVII's Vincent Valentine; Crisis Core, a PSP prequel to FFVII that delves into the origin of the eternal grudge match between Cloud and Sephiroth; DS remakes of FFIII and FFIV; PSP reissues of the Gameboy Advance remakes of FFI and FFII; a downloadable sequel to FFIV; and a couple of Chocobo games for the Wii (Chocobo's Dungeon) and DS (Chocobo Tales).  Most recently we've gotten ANOTHER repackaging of FFIV, this time for the PSP (and including the downloadable sequel and an exclusive new chapter).  Are we seeing a pattern here?

Now this is just Final Fantasy, which means it's just the tip of the iceberg.  Kingdom Hearts has seen some similar releases, each straying further from the genius concept (Final Fantasy meets Disney) that started it, with Kingdom Hearts III just as mysteriously absent as the long-anticipated Final Fantasy XIII - Versus.

To add insult to injury, Square-Enix keeps expanding, having just snapped up Eidos.  You may have noticed that the Square-Enix logo now appears on "Game of the Year" editions of Batman: Arkham Asylum, which is almost as weird as seeing them publish sequels like Kane and Lynch 2 and Just Cause 2.  Now they'll be publishing the new Tomb Raider reboot (and have already repackaged and published a remastered collection of older Tomb Raider games).  And don't even get me started on their toy company or manga publishing.  The old RPG developer has its fingers in a LOT of pies these days.

So what's wrong with this?  I understand this is a business, and the object of any business is to make money, but by absorbing so many properties and studios and dabbling in so many other businesses, Square has sacrificed its greatest asset: the feeling of playing a Square game.  Square games used to be instantly recognizable - there was always a thoughtful balance of gameplay, style, and lingering post-game contentment in any release.  Now there's just a glut of content, with no rhyme or reason.  Compare them to my heroes over at Atlus; many of Atlus' releases are staggeringly unique, but all share the same dedication to quality and creativity, and even when they come from different developers and game studios, share a common stamp of quirkiness that goes hand-in-hand with being an Atlus release.  But with Square, it's becoming more and more about franchise recognition, with some potentially great games getting criminally underdeveloped or undermarketed when they don't quite belong.  Nier, for example, is a fantastic game that could have used a few more months of polish and bigger marketing push, rather than being released in the shadow of FFXIII.   My beloved The World Ends With You, one of the most perfect games ever created, is not relegated to bargain bins.  Next-gen titles like Infinite Undiscovery and The Last Remnant promised classic Square quality, but offered nothing spectacular or memorable.  It was almost as though the eggheads at Square-Enix were putting all their eggs in one basket... but Final Fantasy XIII was in development so long that some of us almost stopped caring.  But was it worth the wait?  Was this really the game hardcore Square fans have been waiting for?  Granted, the characters are much better than XII's, the graphics are jaw-dropping, and the amazing battle system is clearly the product of countless hours of tinkering and testing... but isn't there supposed to be a game in here too?  Word around the campfire is that the upcoming sequel (yep, they're trying that again) will actually address most if not all of the complaints surrounding the first game, but it feels like too little, too late.  I'm happy that Square-Enix is listening to their fans, but really wish they'd spend more time developing their own product (something they used to be legendarily good at) and less time schilling someone else's for a quick buck.  (By the way, that "quick buck" resulted in Square-Enix recently posting a fiscal loss of roughly $150 million.) 

I don't mind Square-Enix going after the big bucks.  But I wish they would put more care into what they're selling.  I'd probably be much happier if they created a separate arm that published games from other studios and dedicated the Square-Enix name to properties developed in-house.  I guess what I'd like best is to see the company move back into a position where I see the logo and get excited, because I know there's something special waiting inside that package.  The kind of feeling I used to get with this:


I miss those days.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Music in Video Games: The Concert Experience

As most of my co-workers can attest, I listen to a lot of video game music.  Part of it's nostalgia - I didn't watch much TV or really listen to the radio as a kid, so Metroid music fills in a lot of those warm fuzzy feeling gaps.  And part of it's an honest appreciation for the genre (much like film music) - I can never get tired of hearing the "Gruntilda's Lair" theme from Banjo-Kazooie. But unlike most other forms of music, video game music can be a little challenging to enjoy and appreciate in groups, in a live concert setting.  This post I'd like to look at two concert series that are attempting to amend that.



I recently had the pleasure of attending a concert that has eluded me for far too long due to its very selective touring cycle: Distant Worlds - The Music of Final Fantasy.  I've been playing Final Fantasy games since, well, they started making them (I can still remember the shocking heft of the first NES title's 80-page instruction manual).  The music for the first nine games was composed by Nobuo Uematsu, a rather ambitious fellow who's become something of a celebrity in the gaming world.  Starting with the very basic 8-bit soundscapes of the NES, his music has evolved over the years as the technology has improved, but after a while it became clear that the sounds we were hearing on our game systems weren't always the sounds in Uematsu's head.  For example, Final Fantasy VI (originally for the SNES) features a lengthy sequence set in an opera house, where the crew of main characters find echoes of their plight mirrored in the drama onstage.  While the SNES was a MIDI-powerhouse at the time, it still didn't do opera justice, so the resulting scenes, while memorable, sounded a little weird:


One of the high points of the Distant Worlds concert was hearing the North American premiere of Uematsu's fully orchestrated and sung version of FFVI's "Draco and Maria" opera.  Also on the program were memorable pieces from Final Fantasy I, II, III, IV, V, VII (the perennial favorite), VIII, IX, X, XI, XIII, and the upcoming XIV.  Uematsu was present at the concert I attended, and his appearance provoked a standing ovation.  Most of the pieces were accompanied by video montages projected on a screen above the orchestra.


These video montages were actually my biggest problem with the entire production.  Some of them were good, and featured not just the sexy pre-rendered cutscenes from many of the later games but actual gameplay footage as well, which brought back a lot of fond memories.  But many of them left one wondering.  For the video accompanying the Chocobo theme, we saw footage from the largely chocobo-free FFVIII, along with a lot of repeated footage from II and XIII (the one where the chocobo chick lives in a character's afro), with a few shots of VII and X thrown in.  Baffling, as FFIX has the most fondly remembered chocobo-related sidequests, and is also the game that features "Vamo alla Flamenco," a delightful Spanish guitar piece that was unfortunately played very poorly at this concert.  Huh?  And when we finally got around to "One-Winged Angel" (the theme of Sephiroth, the fan-favorite villain of FFVII, itself the fan-favorite game of the franchise), we saw very little of Sephiroth himself on the screen.  Instead we got random footage from the CGI film Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children... but not the footage of Sephiroth.  WTF?!?!

It's worth noting that "One-Winged Angel" was saved for last, and was preceded by a long gap filled with applause and fanboys screaming "ONE-WINGED ANGEL!"  It's one of those pieces that every FF fan knows all too well, and audiences are apparently rabid for.  Since the piece includes a chorus and there was no chorus present, the Distant Worlds team decided to try something clever: they had Nobuo Uematsu himself take the stage and conduct the audience (who pretty much all knew the Latin lyrics anyway) while the lyrics scrolled on the screen.  An interesting idea, and a lot of fun, but next to nobody in that room knew how to sing.



All in all, it was a fine show, though for such a high-profile affair (they've been touring this concert for years, in apparently every city BUT New York) there were way too many flubs (the videos were very disappointing) and that Spanish guitar soloist should be dismissed. 

If the Distant Worlds concert felt like video games getting dressed up and going to the opera, then my other video game concert experience, Video Games Live, was like a gamer's Lollapalooza.  Jackie and I attended this on our first anniversary, and I loved every minute of it.



Video Games Live was created and hosted by Jack Wall and Tommy Tallarico, both musicians and specifically game composers who felt that their line of work needed an outlet where it could be celebrated for all the joy and happiness it brings.  They started small but have turned their little idea into an almost full-time obsession that has attracted a traveling company of musicians and gamers and become quite the festive romp.

We had no idea what to expect when we arrived, but it didn't take long to guess what we were in for.  The place was packed with geeks and gamers, half of which looked ready for a convention.  Cosplayers were everywhere, and there was even a Guitar Hero challenge going on in the lobby before the show.  When the lights finally dimmed and the show started, I found myself amazed at the variety of amusements and the sheer energy level of the whole production.  Jackie was annoyed that Tommy Tallarico talked so much, but as the ringleader of this mad musical circus, he kind of had to - he would stop to introduce solo performers, talk about the history of the project and how it had snowballed into what it was now, and give a bit of background about the games whose music they were performing.  There were also interruptions like a costume contest and a few video shorts like this one:


But of course, we came for the music, and the music was wonderfully played... and wonderfully diverse.  We heard Halo.  We heard Kingdom Hearts.  We heard World of Warcraft.  We heard Mega Man.  My favorite moments involved the solo performers.  First up was Martin Leung, who performed a piano medley of Final Fantasy tunes as well some classic selections from Tetris and Super Mario World.  Here's a clip of Martin doing his thing:


Tallarico and Wall apparently discovered Martin on YouTube... which is also where they found Laura Intravia, better known as "Flute Link."  Laura apparently developed this little bit for conventions but his since found bigger audiences for her geek talents.  Those familiar with Ocarina of Time will have no trouble identifying these tunes:



Throughout the show we were treated to plenty of visual aids on the triptych of big screens.  Blizzard was very kind to supply a LOT of footage for the Warcraft suite, and Tallarico and Wall managed to get license clearances for a lot of actual gameplay footage.  Only guess who didn't play nice - SQUARE-ENIX, publisher of the Final Fantasy series.  Maybe because they hold one of the only competing events?  Any Square-Enix music performed yielded a slideshow of cosplay pictures and fan art, which was actually a lot better than what Square-Enix did with Distant Worlds.

Not surprisingly, there was an encore.  And what do you think members of the crowd were clamoring for when Tallarico and company came back out?  That's right - "One-Winged Angel."  I'm beginning to believe it's the "Freebird" of gamer culture.  Check out the energy in the Video Games Live version as compared to Distant Worlds:



Anyhow, it was a wild and wondrous romp, a real multifaceted celebration of gaming culture - both the artists that make these games (and their music) possible and the fans that support them and let them keep creating.  There was so much energy and so much love it was almost impossible to not get caught up in it.  Video Games Live is still touring, and their show is always changing, so I can't wait to see them again.  Maybe they'll do some Banjo-Kazooie!  Or better yet, a tribute to all those great Rare scores from the N64 days (you heard me - get some Jet Force Gemini in there!).  Or some Resident Evil!  How about some Dead Space!  I could go on and on and on... and I hope these guys do too.