Sunday, June 26, 2011

The Legend of Zelda: Attack of the Clones



The Legend of Zelda.  One of the most beloved game franchises ever created, now celebrating its 25th anniversary.  The series' combination of adventuring, puzzle-solving, and exploration has been tweaked and tinkered with countless times over the past quarter-century, yet the core gameplay has remained largely intact.  In this household, if you don't love this franchise, you might as well leave.  As my beloved wife Jackie continues to push me aside in favor of the newly-released 3DS remake of The Ocarina of Time, I thought it might be a good to look at some other games that have - with varying degrees of success - adopted and adapted elements of Zelda's crowd-pleasing formula.


Darksiders
Onward, Epona... I mean, Ruin...


At the bottom of the heap we have Darksiders, an apocalyptic adventure story created and designed by comic book artist Joe Madureira.  You play as War, one of the Four Horsemen, who is summoned to the apocalypse... but it's a trap!  He's actually been made a patsy in an ancient feud between demons and angels.  Before being executed by the neutral Council that oversees the balance between Good and Evil, War begs for a chance to prove his innocence and clear his name.  Thus begins a sprawling adventure across a blasted, post-apocalyptic landscape... only aside from the decor, it's impossible for any seasoned Zelda player not to feel some deja vu.


Darksiders mimics the classic Ocarina of Time in every way it can: a sprawling overworld with huge dungeons (where, of course, the prize item will be crucial in clearing the dungeon and beating the boss), a horse to make traversing the blasted landscape a little easier, a mentor figure that follows you and provides guidance, a mask that lets you see hidden things, a fight against your shadow self, and a hookshot.  (In a rare and fleeting moment of looking outside the Zelda franchise for inspiration, there's also a dual portal gun that functions EXACTLY like the one in Portal, right down to the blue/orange color scheme.)  I'd like to say I enjoyed the throwback to truly classic gameplay, but honestly, I found the game incredibly dull.  The design of the game is pretty much its only selling point, and even that gets old fast.  I had hoped for something fairly easy and pleasant to play through; I got half of what I wanted, at least.

Nier

Everyone loves fishing sidequests, right?

The same year that Square-Enix launched the long-awaited Final Fantasy XIII to huge sales and mixed reviews, they snuck out this curious Zelda clone to dismal sales and much stronger reviews.  Go figure.  It's easy to see why this game wasn't a hit - it's ugly.  No dodging it, it's flat-out ugly.  The textures are largely flat and lacking in detail, the character models get blurry and low-res as they approach the camera, the color palette is very muted and flat.


Once you get past the dismal graphics, though, there's actually a lot to like here.  The story revolves around a nameless father trying to care for his adolescent daughter 1300 years after an undetailed apocalypse has sent mankind back to the middle ages.  Now what survives of humanity huddles in small villages and fends off attacks from shades, aggressive phantoms that prowl the world and attack anything in their path.  Nier borrows its core gameplay from Zelda - offering a huge overworld with several tricky dungeons and even Link's familiar rolling dodge and Z-targeting - but is never afraid to branch out and try other things, as well as incorporate classic Square elements like excessive level grinding and item farming (elements that were notably absent in FFXIII).  Most of the game's nods to other games actually occur in quirky, light-hearted, and comical moments, often when you least expect them.  When you journey into the desert to help the young King of Facade search for his lost mask, you are rewarded with the Ocarina item find pose when he finds it.  An investigation into a supposedly haunted manor shifts the game into a black-and-white fixed camera style, and anyone who's played the first Resident Evil can't help but recognize both the layout and camera placement in the dining room (you can almost hear Barry Burton: "I hope that's not Chris's blood...").  Gameplay can suddenly and unexpectedly shift to a 2D sidescroller view, or a 3D isometric view (not unlike the X-Men and Marvel Ultimate Alliance games).  There's even a "dungeon" that text-only!  It's a very mixed bag, but one full of pleasant little surprises.  Throw in beautiful music, an engaging story, and multiple endings that gradually deepen your understanding of the characters, and you've got a real winner.  Plus, a completely unlooked-for cinematic nod to the old Charlton Heston epic El Cid: at the game's halfway point, a hugely traumatic event occurs, and when we pick up five years later, our main character (much like Heston's after the intermission) is older, meaner, and covered in battle scars (and also missing an eye).  Badass.  Fun fact: the magic book Grimoire Weiss that follows the main character around and prattles on endlessly (thus fulfilling the Navi-requirement for this game) is voiced by Liam O'Brien... who also voiced War in Darksiders.

3D Dot Game Heroes

Beware the Cuccos!
 Leave it to my guys over at Atlus to bring something weird to the table.  Drawing inspiration from the early NES era of adventure gaming, From Software designed this punchy title to be essentially exactly like the original Legend of Zelda... just updated a little.  The 8-bit pixellated Kingdom of Dotnia is troubled by a dark menace that was once defeated by a legendary hero guided by six powerful sages (any of this sound familiar?).  Years later, the current king has grown tired of the way the kingdom looks and demands everything be updated to 3D.  Wouldn't you know it, a scheming Dark Bishop has found a way to unlock the ancient curse and once again, a hero is needed.  To get a feel for how zany this really is, you have to see it:



I just started playing this, but I'm already loving it.  It's very light, very fluffy, and very, very silly, but all lovingly made to capture everything you loved about old 8-bit games, just with a goofy twist.  In-jokes are everywhere: when the king hires you to quest for the sacred sword of legend, he hands you a wooden sword with the words "It's dangerous to be alone!"  Players of the original Final Fantasy may remember a talking broom in Matoya's cave that taught you a convenient "spell" - "Push B select!" written backwards - that opened up the world map.  Here, a character will teach you, in backwards writing, of course, to "Press L1 to open the map!"  Final Fantasy's resident inventor/engineer Cid is reimagined as Dic ("don't get sucked into his schemes!").  The blocky foes you face are generic versions of Tektites and Moblins, right down to the color schemes.  You can even attack blocky little chickens in the villages (and face their wrath!).  Zanier still, there's a character editor that allows you to create your own pixellated hero.  I haven't quite mastered that yet (I couldn't even build a proper Gummi ship, so I don't hold out much hope) but it's enticing.


Okami


Possibly the best Zelda ripoff ever is the ambitious Okami, brainchild of talented (if slightly wacko) game director Hideki Kamiya.  Like Darksiders, Okami lifts the Ocarina of Time formula shamelessly, but offers so many charming new twists and gorgeous art design that you almost don't notice.  You play as the sun goddess Amaterasu, incarnate in the form of a white wolf, trying to stop the evil eight-headed demon Orochi from dominating feudal Japan.  The game design resembles a cross between classic Japanese watercolor and brush work and a web cartoon - and it works beautifully.  The truly unique element is the celestial brush, an item that will let you channel your divine powers by freezing the game and painting on the screen - a vine to lift you up, a rope to cross to a distant platform, a bomb, etc.  It's an awesome mechanic, one that lent itself very naturally to the Wii port (the game was originally for PS2).  A snarky sense of humor, lush environments, a bazillion unlockables and side quests, and monsters drawn (literally!) from old Japanese catalogs of yokai make for an immensely enjoyable game.  If you're a Zelda fan, you seriously owe it to yourself to check this one out.  Let's have a look:



So there.  Just because we have to wait for Skyward Sword doesn't mean we can't pretend to play Zelda in the meantime, right?  Just skip Darksiders.  And play Okami.  Seriously, play it.

P.S.  Jackie would be disappointed if I didn't post this little reminder of the original classic:








1 comment:

  1. I love you. And I do love that commercial. But I haven't been "pushing" you aside. More like nudging, really. And how many times have you left me to fend for myself after spending some time with your Xbox? =P

    ReplyDelete